• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

RIP Andy Rourke

And so, just like that, the classic Smiths lineup its over... forever. We never will see again Morrissey, Marr, Rourke and Joyce together again. One rare case of band wich never came back. Last show in 1988. The Eagles who, said it will only come back "when hell freezes" it did many times. Guns and Roses, wich swore each other to death, the same. Not The Smiths. This was a real deal.

I know right :crying:
Getting together with Joyce was pretty much never going to happen but Morrissey, Marr, and Rourke...we can but dream
 
I've always paid more attention to Johnny Marr (not sure why he's getting flamed a bit here), but was just thinking while listening to The Smiths - there are a ton of rock/pop songs where a cover band bass player could just play root notes and it would be fine. These Smiths songs would collapse without the full bass line. I should have paid more attention years ago, am just now realizing how Andy was in many ways the spark that raised The Smiths beyond the thousand other post-punk bands to one of my all-time favorites. RIP Andy
 
Really? One of the most iconic bands of the 80's, with an influence that has continued through the years. While "How Soon Is Now" was somewhat atypical of the rest of their output, I'd say it's one of the top ten songs that defined the decade. A game changing band as they brought back focus to the guitar after the earlier synth-centric wave, in the post-punk/indie/college rock world.

Marr's intricate chimey jangle arpeggiation was a relief from the endless showboat shredding otherwise going on in guitarland. Morrissey may have been The Pope Of Mope, his lyrics almost laughable in its self-pity, but it struck a nerve with scores of marginalized or shunned youth at the time.

But driving all that was Rourke(with Joyce), having forged a new style, not flashy or show-off like a lot of bass at that time, but when you analyze what what he was doing, you realize his uniqueness and quiet brilliance.

Nice break down. I would throw James Honeyman Scott into the mix of leading guitarists of that era as well. I feel both JHS and Marr were influenced by the jangley guitars of the 60's West Coast such as the Byrds. YMMV
 
Johnny Marr is a brilliant guitarist and composer. And Morrissey was a fine singer and lyricist, regardless what one thinks about some of his recent statements (which I myself don't agree with.)

Andy Rourke's contribution to the band was as important as Marr and Morrissey even if he (criminally) doesn't get the same fawning attention.

And let's not make the mistake of forgetting Mike Joyce. If you need a reminder about his importance I recommend you listen to Rank. Play it LOUD.
 

Latest posts