• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Roscoe Club

I'm hoping that maybe new pickups in my G&L JB-2 will scratch my itch. It's a nice little bass and has a really fast neck, and was a gift from my wife so I'd like to use it once in a while, like jazz quartet gigs, jams, things like that.
 
Can you afford not to? ;)

It sounds like you're mind is set on doing this mod and you want approval from the rest of us. ;) In that case, I fully endorse the mod as long as it's reversible in case you don't like it.

My mind isn't set. I waffle all the time. I got an email form a friend who builds and does that mod to all his basses and loves it. I also hear from many people to leave well enough alone as I love this bass as is. It takes me weeks or months to debate myself in or out of a purchase.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nightman
Can you afford not to? ;)

It sounds like you're mind is set on doing this mod and you want approval from the rest of us. ;) In that case, I fully endorse the mod as long as it's reversible in case you don't like it.

Well, if that's the case, then I vote you get the like new Roscoe 4'er. It's only twice the cost of the mods, but it gives you more options. And it's what you want, which should trump all reasons.
 
Sometimes I tinker with my SKB 3005 to get different tones to fit original recordings, but mostly just find the best tone for the venue. Still, $700 is cheaper then a buying a cheap bass which will feel inferior to a Roscoe. Sorry, not much help.

FWIW, a year ago I bought 3 PUPs to put into my Dingwall SJ5XXX (it has neo's, I bought alnico's) and 2 are still sitting (1 made its way into the bridge position of my SPJ5). Usually the want is stronger than the need.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SteveC and Nightman
Debating again the modification of my beloved Roscoe Century Standard Plus 5.
View attachment 2941940
I love this bass. Love how it plays, looks, feels and sounds.
I also play some songs where a P bass tone would be so awesome. I can kind of get that with this bass. Neck pup, add a little mid, roll off some treble, etc. Some times a J bass would be awesome. Bridge pup, add a little bass, etc. I know one bass can't be all things. I also know there are a lot of basses out there with dual coil pups and 3-way toggles for series, parallel and single coil options that people seem to really like.

For those of you Roscoe players that have such things, what have you used and done? Brands? Active/Passive for even more options? Is it worth the cost? I'm guessing I'd have to replace everything:

active/passive 3 (or 4) band 4 knob preamp
mini toggle for each pup
new dual coil pickups
Shipping to and from Roscoe to get it done

This could be upwards of $700 to get done. After all that, would I get what I want? Obviously nothing will sound like a P except a P, a J like a J, I get it.

Thoughts?
Product recommendations?
700 wow. For that coin you can have your choice of some really nice used P style axes from Fender to Lakland.
 
Well, if that's the case, then I vote you get the like new Roscoe 4'er. It's only twice the cost of the mods, but it gives you more options. And it's what you want, which should trump all reasons.
It's really hard to ignore a $1,500 Roscoe classic jazz 4. And a Pacman noted, it's routed for JJ or PJ from the factory. Just need a different pickguard and P pup and bam...P/J...Or I'd just leave it after I fell in love with the jazz sound again as that was my go to sound for years before I went Modulus and then Roscoe.

If I didn't like the Roscoe Classic neck I could probably flip that bass for no loss as well as it's such a great price.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nightman
It's really hard to ignore a $1,500 Roscoe classic jazz 4. And a Pacman noted, it's routed for JJ or PJ from the factory. Just need a different pickguard and P pup and bam...P/J...Or I'd just leave it after I fell in love with the jazz sound again as that was my go to sound for years before I went Modulus and then Roscoe.

If I didn't like the Roscoe Classic neck I could probably flip that bass for no loss as well as it's such a great price.

+1 - I think those waffles are done!! :thumbsup:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bass Viking
I texted a pic to my wife. Said it's hard to not buy a $1,500 Roscoe weather you need it or not. She said it "looks nice" and I need a birthday and fathers day gift...
I'd never have her buy it as if I sell it that would be bad, but almost a passive "ok" from her. Have to feel things out a bit. She bought me my G&L JB-2 that I have used with flats for "more "traditional" jazz and pit gigs. It's a nice bass and would be better with new pickups. So I already have a "jazz" bass in the house. :help:

The only other issue (in my mind) is that I have been playing 5 strings for a while. There are about 4 songs right now in the cover band that really need a B string - Uptown Funk for example - and I hate changing basses mid set...especially between a passive and active. Hate to mess up the mix.

1st world problems.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Drkwdsman@yahoo
I don't see what the problem is @SteveC ...If I had been on here for a couple months wanting another bass and upon finding exactly what I was looking for, and the wife put her stamp of approval on it, I would be posting a NBD thread on here lol. I feel like your overthinking the process entirely to much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JOME77 and SteveC
I don't see what the problem is @SteveC ...If I had been on here for a couple months wanting another bass and upon finding exactly what I was looking for, and the wife put her stamp of approval on it, I would be posting a NBD thread on here lol. I feel like your overthinking the process entirely to much.

I do tend to do that. I have to make sure I'd be OK with a 4 string. I've thought about going back to a passive 4 string for a few reasons for a while. I suppose it wouldn't be that big a deal to swap basses, set the output on the active bass to match best I can, use it for the 3-4 songs I need it and use the jazz for the rest.

I'll quit posting and clogging up the thread and try to decide what to do.
 
I'll quit posting and clogging up the thread and try to decide what to do.

Hey now! What fun is that?! Clog away!

(For the record, my two cents...don't mess with the Roscoe you have that you really like. You have a passive 4-string J in the G&L. You really wanna P? Get a used P or PJ for a price you can afford and be done with it OR keep rolling with the nice kit you already have at your disposal and put this out of your mind.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: SteveC

Latest posts