OK, so what didja think about it? Any big difference between it and the usual passive PBass?I did that for a few years with my Ibanez RB630: EMG P and BTS system...
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Settle an argument. (Fender vs. FSO vs. non-FSO)
- Thread starter Greenman72
- Start date
I voted "Not Fender, but FSO" only because I don't really consider a bass to be different if it's got the same pickup arrangement in a different body. I wouldn't really look at a non-FSO thing and call it a P bass, but if it's electronically the same as a P bass, I'd call them equivalent.
Agree.
According to some BS rule, Macca, Lemmy, Stanley Clarke, John Entwistle (I could go on) are not bassists!
But to answer the OPs DA Q.
A precision bass is any bass that Fender* put a Precision logo on.
Any bass that isn't made by Fender that doesn't have a Precision logo, isn't a Precision bass.
Any answer that isn't this pure opinion and meaningless.
*Including Squier
I fell in love with the Precision shape as a teenager a very long time ago and it's still my favourite body shape. There are others I like but not many. The Precision pickup location is also my favourite spot but I don't necessarily need the Fender style split pickup. I have others located there that sound great.
IMHO, only a Fender Precision is a Precision, simply because that's the official name of that specific Fender model. (This applies to Squiers also, BTW). Basses that look like Precision basses with a split-coil pickup in the right spot are Precision-style basses. Non-FSO's are whatever their model name is, with or without a split-coil pickup.
That said, I don't have a problem with Precision- or Jazz-style basses being referred to as P- or J-basses.
My shiny new P5...!
Unfortunately, I had to sell it awhile back... /sadface
I want to put together a similar Warmoth '72 Precision fretless PJ build someday; Daphne Blue body, wenge neck & ebony fingerboard, red tort pickguard...!
Last edited:
I spose when the average bass Joe and Janette think about a Pbass, the iconic split coil comes to mind. The original scpu Precision Bass is overshadowed I guess
Last edited:
Super strict answer: When you say Precision bass, it can only be a Fender or a Squier, since the Fender company holds the rights to name it like this.
Strict answer: Any FSO with the split pickup in the right position qualifies as a Precision bass.
Q: "What do you play?" "
A: "A Nash PB-59"
Q: "What's that?"
A: "A Precision bass made by Nash"
Strict answer: Any FSO with the split pickup in the right position qualifies as a Precision bass.
Q: "What do you play?" "
A: "A Nash PB-59"
Q: "What's that?"
A: "A Precision bass made by Nash"
Well... I voted "Carrots", since I'm a Carrot Party guy. But... since "Inquiring minds want to know", here goes...
Personally, I'm old enough that I'll never have a "birth year" electric bass - and I'm left handed, to boot. But, growing up? A Fender Precision Bass - was the only Precision Bass. And, when non-Fender versions began to show up, they were not Precision Basses; they were rip-offs. But, times change, and now there are a lot of basses that people think of as "Precision Basses". And, I suppose they are - whether I like it or not...
And, to be honest? I don't I really care much, one way or the other. Still, There is only one Precision Bass in my 27 bass "Herd" - and it's a '78 Fender. I do have several other basses that could be considered in the same barnyard as a "real" P-Bass, though. I have a 30" Warmoth Mini-Precision, that was built to be a "Mini Me" clone of my Fender. It certainly sounds like a P-Bass. My 31" scale, headless aluminum-necked Kramer Duke has a Schaller "Twin-J" pickup that can be split into a Split-coil configuration. Sounds pretty P-Bass-ish, to be honest. And, my G&L Kiloton, with it's 3-way switch in the center position? Sounds sorta like a P-Bass - to my ears, anyway. Might sound more like one if it had frets, though... I suppose my G&L ASAT Bass, in neck pickup/passive mode, might sound sorta like a P-Bass, but I've never paid much attention; I don't usually play it that way. Same goes for my EBMM 4HH Stingray Special, with the switch in the #5 position...
So... bottom line? For an old fart like me? "Precision Bass" means it has "Fender" on the headstock. But, I'm not going to be a fanatic about it, as far as anyone else is concerned. I'm happy with the 47 y/o Real Deal that I've owned for 37 years; you be happy with whatever you think is a P-Bass...
"Precision bass" is a model name. Therefore, it must be a Fender (or Squier) model and can have a variety of pickup types, as Fender sees fit, such as single-coil, split-coil, PJ, or even two Jazz pickups in the case of some 5-string Precision basses.
If it says "Precision bass" on the headstock along with a Fender or Squier logo, then it's a "Precision bass" IMHO.
If it says "Precision bass" on the headstock along with a Fender or Squier logo, then it's a "Precision bass" IMHO.
Carrots:
- Léo called it a precision cause this was the first (or one of the first) bass with frets; which means easier precision when playing note that on a double bass which was the norm before.
- Did the first precision bass have a split coil ?
So all existing fretted bass are "Precision"
- Léo called it a precision cause this was the first (or one of the first) bass with frets; which means easier precision when playing note that on a double bass which was the norm before.
- Did the first precision bass have a split coil ?
So all existing fretted bass are "Precision"
EdwardofHuncote
I Still Dream of Jeannie
- Aug 21, 2013
- 6,669
- 2
- 16,477
- Disclosures
- I privately own and operate a local musical instument repair shop.
Okay... I looked through four pages of posts for the carrots. The carrots are leading in the poll... where are the the freakin' carrots?! 
I've still got three Pbasses , Fenders , both split and single coil , but don't own a Jazz bass. I do have a couple of these though.
Depends on your snob level. Your FSO can say Squier,hondo, Glarry, and others on the headstock and play perfect. Will you be ok with it not saying Fender on the headstock?
Well, there goes 45 years of practice for nothing.....thanks for letting me know that I'm not a "true" bassist. I'll go apologize to everyone I've ever played with, cancel all my upcoming gigs, and refund the money I've made as a fake bassist/scam artist.
