• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Short scale basses

Hi Justin,

I'm curious about your experience with recording and gigging short-scale basses.

For my part I first started paying attention to them when I read a Bass Player interviewcirca 2001 with Robert DeLeo and he shared that a lot of Stone Temple Pilots songs were recorded on short-scales (a Limgar, Orlando, Danelectro and Fender Musicmaster)... I was pretty shocked that Big Empty was one of these songs, but up to that point I didn't have any real recording experience.

The conventional wisdom of bass (i.e. what the old guys I kept meeting when I was starting out in college would always tell me) tends to be that Fender was the default standard for recording because that's what studios were used to and because shortscales, etc. were considered inferior/muddy/student models/etc. I didn't at the time know better because I had never had the chance to try any.

Was there a point at which guys started using these oddball instruments for recording, where they generally hadn't previously? Or, was the conventional wisdom bogus?

Or, was it not really until the 90s that recording technology got to the point where it was easier to work with something like a Limgar?
 
These "oddball" instruments were always used for recording...perhaps more so than they were used live for certain players. But overall, I'd say they fell somewhat out of fashion basically from latter half of the 70's through probably the mid '90's, based on my experience and research. Before the mid 70's or so, short scale instruments were just as prevalent everywhere. Sure, you always had to have a "Fender bass" around (meaning P bass usually), but all kinds of folks had short scale, Guilds, Framuses, Hofners, Burns, Kay, Danelectro, Silvertone, Harmony, Airline, Supro, Gretsch, Mosrite, and so many others. I just basically try to stick with my own truth that anything labeled "conventional wisdom" is immediately suspect. I'm sure some other folks can chime in with some other interesting historical factoids/anecdotes. Oh - and 90's recording tech (or that of any other era) was never really an impediment or enhancement...the choices have all had to do with (on one hand) fashion and taste, and on the other hand more thoughtful sonic considerations.
 

Latest posts