Should I make this trade?

[bench]

A passive fourstring p with a rosewood board vs. an active fivestring j with a maple board. Hard to imagine that you don't have a preference... Fourstring for me if it helps...

 

[rojo412]

You know me, brotha... that Valenti is a hottie!

But you have other 5'ers, so the Fender is probably the better move as a keeper.
Also: red.

 

[Double E]

A passive fourstring p with a rosewood board vs. an active fivestring j with a maple board. Hard to imagine that you don't have a preference... Fourstring for me if it helps...

I dig them both. I have a collection of basses with just about every combination of features. The P wins in this case.

 

[DionClassic]

The black one just looks so boring

 

[Double E]

You know me, brotha... that Valenti is a hottie!

But you have other 5'ers, so the Fender is probably the better move as a keeper.
Also: red.

I had the pleasure of owning this very Valenti for about a year. It is pretty awesome but I do indeed have a great arsenal of 5ers including Sandberg, Lecompte and Marleaux.

What I don't have is an ACF Custom!