Just wanted to drop back in to apologize to you, Flux. Calling you 'nutz' was rude and uncalled for. I sincerely apologize, very sorry for saying that. No, the mods didn't put me up to this, but they probably should have. Anyhow...
I do admire your drive and creativity. Really.
It's just that your (extreme) quest to even out the sound of your strings says to me that maybe you're playing the wrong instrument. I feel that the differing sounds across strings is simply a feature of the instrument to be embraced, rather than a problem in search of a solution, and I think that most would agree.
But that doesn't matter. Do what suits you, carry on sir.
You're entitled to your opinion ... if you want to think I'm extreme (or nutz) for doing what I'm doing, that's ok with me!
However if most would agree that I am playing the wrong instrument (as in the wrong model of bass guitar) because I don't care for the way the EA pair sounds different then the DG pair, then I guess the last 27 basses I have owned were also the wrong instrument ... that is, in the opinion of most. I have not owned a bass yet that didn't cause me to play the DG strings closer to the neck than the EA strings to get the tone to balance out more evenly.
If you meant that I should be playing something other than a bass guitar, weeellllll .. I DO play other instruments (guitar, keys, organ, synths). However I prefer the bass for certain sounds and certain types of musical uses.
I don't think that coming up with a 2-channel bass, and a switching setup operated via footswitch is "extreme" at all. It's no more "extreme" than anyone that uses a pedalboard that 2 feet long and a 18 inches deep to produce the sounds that THEY like, now is it! It's no more extreme than buying amp after amp in the "quest for tone". It's no more extreme than any attempt to make a bass better suited for a given person's needs. It's simply another set of FX that produce a desired sound. Not only that, the 2 channel bass setup has proven to be highly useful for a number of other things. When used with the switching and mixer setup I came up with to conquer the string-sound-imbalance I have created a 2-preset pickup mixer! I can switch between two preset pickup mixes (or ~blends~) with a footswitch and back again instantly and on the fly. Since the footswitch is a momentary switch it only holds the setup in "preset B" for as long as I hold the switch down with my foot. The instant I let up I'm back to "preset A" ... and I can switch between presets so quickly that it happens between 16th (32nd?) notes ... (let's see someone do THAT with a blend knob on their bass in the middle of a phrase!).
I'll conclude with adding that I have been told a number of times that the string tone imbalance issue is something that bothers more people than just myself.
But y'see .. in the end .... none of it matters. This world (and this forum) are big enough for both types of people. Those that feel that the EA strings sound different than the DG strings, and those that think that the ones that feel the string pairs sound different are playing the wrong instruments.
Oh, and apology accepted, but was unnecessary. However it's good to see you have a conscience and that you actually listen to it. That virtue is becoming more rare.
Thanks again.
