i was actually just pickin' at ERIC31 in post #3.
while i wouldn't say "great", it's next to impossible to make a p bass/svt sound like crap!
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Sid Vicious could actually play bass...kinda.
- Thread starter IpseDixit
- Start date
i was actually just pickin' at ERIC31 in post #3.
while i wouldn't say "great", it's next to impossible to make a p bass/svt sound like crap!
Despite all his childish bravado and on stage posturing, it must have been pretty daunting for him underneath it all. After all he'd only been playing about 10 months in total at this point. Talk about 'thrown in at the deep end'. Mind you it ain't very complex music.
Yeah it really wasn't but again was he really a bass player? I don't know but he's a punk icon and I'm not complaining.😝 I love the sex pistols.
- Feb 24, 2004
- 4,103
- 642
- 68
- Disclosures
- Endorsing Artist: Phantom Guitars, Eastwood Guitars
Actually, I think it's the session bassist playing behind the curtain, as the Pistols were rumoured to have done.
When you watch the vid, the bass keeps playing while Sid flourishes his hand away from the strings. Embarrassing.
Check this out, around 18:17: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ooIz_Di2w3g
I think Johnny wanted Sid's vox turned down when he called out to the sound man. Cuz Sid couldn't sing either.
When you watch the vid, the bass keeps playing while Sid flourishes his hand away from the strings. Embarrassing.
Check this out, around 18:17: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ooIz_Di2w3g
I think Johnny wanted Sid's vox turned down when he called out to the sound man. Cuz Sid couldn't sing either.
There's an ancient interview with Dee Dee Ramone from some music rag (International Musician, perhaps?) where he talks about how Sid Vicious used to call him up all the time and play the Wouldn't It Be Cool If We Formed A Band Together? fantasy game.
Dee Dee kept trying to blow him off, but Sid would persist, and often ask "If we were in a band together, would you still want to play bass?" Whenever Dee Dee would reply "Yes" Sid would say "That's good, 'cuz I wanna play guitar."
Sid wasn't as bad as people make out, but it is convenient to say he was terrible as it allows The Sex Pistols, and punk in general, to be filed away as a band/genre.
I can't understand how "punk" got so popular. What is the appeal of being a whiny, ****** person with little to no talent? It sounds like that's what being punk is all about.
Rebellion against the establisment. Taking back fate in their own hands. Spirit of the times. Hard times back then and youth felt ****** over by the previous generations.
If you're into The Police, you'll read stories of how they'd hide their chops in order to get gigs.
"kill someone, kill yourself". Gripping.
Great comedy around here. I love it when you guys go into your "all music is great no matter how bad it is mode".
Now, stop it.
Great comedy around here. I love it when you guys go into your "all music is great no matter how bad it is mode".
Now, stop it.
My understanding is that Steve Jones played all the bass lines on the Sex Pistols albums and Sid never did. He was that bad.
I's SP fan but its sad to me that during the time they were around (my teens) My friends and I thought of them as a joke band. We used to hear about them and read about them in Cream magazine and they were made out to be like a stupid pop boy band.
maybe it was us but we kind of dissed them although secretly I loved them. We worshiped Sabbath, Kiss, BOC, Aerosmith...that was rock to us.
Thanks for this link. I will listen to it all with earbuds when I can. I love the history and mystery of the SP.
maybe it was us but we kind of dissed them although secretly I loved them. We worshiped Sabbath, Kiss, BOC, Aerosmith...that was rock to us.
Thanks for this link. I will listen to it all with earbuds when I can. I love the history and mystery of the SP.
Ha I'd go see the Sex Pistols any day over Grand Funk Railroad. There isn't any other four musicians in the world that could make it sound like the Sex Pistols. But I'd bet John Ritchie could play the bass line for "some kind of wonderful" haha. Sex Pistols WERE great.
Yeah, Sid was not that great, but could play a little when not strung out.
That was the main issue. During the American tour they pretty much kept him clean and his playing sounded better for it (which is why he carved "gimme a fix" into his chest. Slight touch of withdrawal there..)
According to John Lydon, after the sound check before the actual show, Sid disappeared for a bit with Malcom McClaren and came back stoned.
Which helped lead to the implosion after the show..
That was the main issue. During the American tour they pretty much kept him clean and his playing sounded better for it (which is why he carved "gimme a fix" into his chest. Slight touch of withdrawal there..)
According to John Lydon, after the sound check before the actual show, Sid disappeared for a bit with Malcom McClaren and came back stoned.
Which helped lead to the implosion after the show..
Ridiculous. He slams a note, holds it, flails his arm, and then starts playing again, with no other bass notes sounding in the interim.
Haters gonna hate.
Not bad for a Grand Funk Railroad fan.
GFR are typically lampooned as being such a basic and brainless act that Homer Simpson likes them. "Ah, but Mel Schacker was a brilliant and innovative bassist" I hear you clamor.... instantly activating "all music is great no matter how bad it is mode".
