• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Single Malt Scotch!

Worth getting? I've looked at the Japanese whiskies every once and a while, but my inner single malt cork sniffer has prevented me from buying any bottle that says "blend"..
There is a huge difference between a grain blend and a malt blend and the better Japanese malt blends are incredible. The only reason in fact that they can't be labeled 'scotch' is because they weren't made in Scotland, even though the flavor profiles place them squarely in scotch territory. Taketsuru 17 was awarded best blend in the world twice for very good reason.
Taketsuru Pure Malt is very good, and in fact the only Taketsuru that I haven't liked was the 12.

Hibiki 17 and 30 are both incredible, especially the 30, and if you ever have the chance to get to their distillery you'll also get a chance to sample the separate components of their malt blends, my favorite being the mizunara.
 
There is a huge difference between a grain blend and a malt blend and the better Japanese malt blends are incredible. The only reason in fact that they can't be labeled 'scotch' is because they weren't made in Scotland, even though the flavor profiles place them squarely in scotch territory. Taketsuru 17 was awarded best blend in the world twice for very good reason.
Taketsuru Pure Malt is very good, and in fact the only Taketsuru that I haven't liked was the 12.

Hibiki 17 and 30 are both incredible, especially the 30, and if you ever have the chance to get to their distillery you'll also get a chance to sample the separate components of their malt blends, my favorite being the mizunara.

Wow, thanks for the intel! :thumbsup:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Akami
Wow, thanks for the intel! :thumbsup:
I left out one important item about Hibiki; easiest distillery in Japan to get to! Right in between Osaka and Kyoto, only 5 minute walk from the Yamazaki train station! They also have a range of scotches (Balvenie!) there available for sampling, as does Hasegawa Liquors in the Yaesu Underground area adjoining Tokyo Station.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tombowlus
There is a huge difference between a grain blend and a malt blend and the better Japanese malt blends are incredible. The only reason in fact that they can't be labeled 'scotch' is because they weren't made in Scotland, even though the flavor profiles place them squarely in scotch territory. Taketsuru 17 was awarded best blend in the world twice for very good reason.
Taketsuru Pure Malt is very good, and in fact the only Taketsuru that I haven't liked was the 12.

Hibiki 17 and 30 are both incredible, especially the 30, and if you ever have the chance to get to their distillery you'll also get a chance to sample the separate components of their malt blends, my favorite being the mizunara.

Thanks for the info. :thumbsup:

I already checked the price and availability..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Akami
I just discovered this thread, cool, bass players that drink Scotch! I just decided to explore the beverage a couple of years ago because of a tasting someone had, I was never really was a fan before then, but I know now that was because of what I was exposed top; I'm sure you know what I mean. I always liked smoked foods, someone said try a smoky Scotch and I liked it, so now my favorites are the Islay single malts. It's nice to see that of the 20 or so Scotches I've tried in my short time so far that my favorite, Lagavulin 16, is well regarded.

136 pages! Wow, I'll be back in a couple of weeks!
 
Last edited:
I just discovered this thread, cool, bass players that drink Scotch! I just decided to explore the beverage a couple of years ago because of a tasting someone had, I was never really was a fan before then, but I know now that was because of what I was exposed top; I'm sure you know what I mean. I always liked smoked foods, someone said try a smoky Scotch and I liked it, so now my favorites are the Islay single malts. It's nice to see that of the 20 or so Scotches I've tried in my short time so far that my favorite, Lagavulin 16, is well regarded.

136 pages! Wow, I'll be back in a couple of weeks!
Lots of Islay fans here! When I saw there was a new post I hurried up to see what I was drinking tonight and you settled it for me. Lagavulin 12! If you haven't tried it yet you're in for a nice surprise!
 
Thanks, I'm sure I'll try it eventually. I'm planning on trying the base (bass?) level of each of the Islays I can find, and trying a few other smoky/peaty single malts also just to see what I might enjoy. I've already tried and enjoyed the Ardbeg 10, Caol Ila 12, Laphroaig 10 and Bowmore 12 and another couple, don't have my notes with me. The Ardbeg, my first, was a tad brutal, but I liked that more than I thought I would! lol. I think the Caol Ila is nice.

I've also tried a few Speysides as well as quite a few of the Highland Glen+++s etc. but didn't care for them so much. Although I thought the Cragellachie Speyside was good, but maybe that's because a friend bought it for me! Free is my favorite flavor.

I actually never thought I'd like Scotch, but that was probably because of some of the blends I tried. Since I like smoky foods a lot, mostly mine, someone suggested the Islays and here I am, hooked!

All this in good time as a retiree budget allows, anyway. After exploring a while, I'll look at the finer versions of the distilleries I particularly liked. Having said that, I don't foresee many times when I won't have some of this 16 around!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Akami
Just got back from a trip to Europe with the family, and picked up a couple of cute little bottles in duty free.

IMG_0436_zpsmvxpy6zf.jpg
 
I do love my Jura whisky's especially the Duirach's Own.
Glengoyne another nice wee tipple. Hope you enjoy.
Also hope the trip was good fun. Whereabouts did you go ?
Dave

We spent most of our time in Germany (visiting relatives), but also hit Luxembourg, France, Switzerland, and one dinner in Austria. Great trip! It was the first time for the kids (16 and 14) and it made a big impression.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dmccombe7
Sounds like a great vacation!

A Jura is one of the next ones on my list to try. Any reason not to start with the 10yo? Would the Prophesy be better for my preference for the more smoky/peated whiskys? The cinnamon part kind of scares me, I'm not so much interested in an upscale version of Fireball, although I'm sure it wouldn't be anything like that. The only other one on their website that mentions smokiness is the Journey, but I don't see any available online.

Other pending candidates on my quest for smoke include Port Askaig, Port Charlotte and maybe one of the other iterations from Ardbeg or Laphroaig. Further suggestions?

Edit: We were on a crossing two months ago and ended up in Portugal and Spain; the Scotch selection at the duty free was very limited, but the black tag Iberico Hams and the local Vermouths we did try were amazing.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: tombowlus
Sounds like a great vacation!

A Jura is one of the next ones on my list to try. Any reason not to start with the 10yo? Would the Prophesy be better for my preference for the more smoky/peated whiskys? The cinnamon part kind of scares me, I'm not so much interested in an upscale version of Fireball, although I'm sure it wouldn't be anything like that. The only other one on their website that mentions smokiness is the Journey, but I don't see any available online.

Other pending candidates on my quest for smoke include Port Askaig, Port Charlotte and maybe one of the other iterations from Ardbeg or Laphroaig. Further suggestions?

The Prophesy is most definintely peaty! You should drive down from Oak Harbor sometime and we can share a few drams! :thumbsup:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Akami
Sounds great, thanks Tom! If I could ask, where do you purchase most of your Scotches? Bassett's in Port Clinton seems to have a very good selection.

By the way, the new band is playing Winestein's on August 4th, stop on out and give us a listen some time, maybe get up for a couple if you want! We've been playing out for just about one year now; good guys, my first no-drama band. Mostly rock, but everything from Porgy and Bess to Daft Punk, and a lot of songs with two- and three-part harmony.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dmccombe7
Sounds great, thanks Tom! If I could ask, where do you purchase most of your Scotches? Bassett's in Port Clinton seems to have a very good selection.

By the way, the new band is playing Winestein's on August 4th, stop on out and give us a listen some time, maybe get up for a couple if you want! We've been playing out for just about one year now; good guys, my first no-drama band. Mostly rock, but everything from Porgy and Bess to Daft Punk, and a lot of songs with two- and three-part harmony.

I buy a few a Bassett's, but I get a lot via mail order or trips through the duty free shops.

What is your band's name? That sounds like a fun mix. My band, Stranger Than Fiction, is playing at Weinstein's on Aug. 11th, and a Pub 400 on July 21st. I think I will be over at Put-in-Bay crewing on a sail boat for Bay Week on Aug. 4th, but if not, I will try and make it out!
 
We're The Feds. Yes, mostly stuff we just like playing.
The Feds Band

Darn, we're playing Tall Timbers campground on the 11th and I was thinking of going along with my drummer to Sycamore Lake Winery near Columbus Grove on the 21st, I think we have a gig there later this year, but I'll check. We've got more in the area coming up later in the year, I'll let you know.

FlyerNate.gif
 
Other pending candidates on my quest for smoke include Port Askaig, Port Charlotte and maybe one of the other iterations from Ardbeg or Laphroaig. Further suggestions?
If you can ever find an affordable bottling of Port Ellen it remains one of the most memorable scotches I've ever had.

For Ardbeg, definitely find a bottle of Corryvreckan. I've always got at least one bottle on hand. Laphroaig Quarter Cask is also another one I try to keep around but if you had to choose between the two, Corryvreckan is one of the best.
 
Thank you Akami, I will definitely head that direction.

Interesting Scotch-related story; you guys might like this. Back in about '96 I knew absolutely nothing about Scotch, and I was really starting to get into the continental beer, real ale and craft beer scene which was just starting at the time. The wife was a travel agent and we won a trip to England, so I was excited to try as many beers as I could. We took the kids over, and took the bullet train from London to Glasgow after a few days. Then we rented a car, attempting Inverness, but only made it as far as Fort William, which turned out to be very nice actually; driving there was a whole 'nother tale best told over a wee dram by a fire, though. Let's just say we're lucky to be alive, but we did see some of the most beautiful land on earth. Breathtaking in early spring!!!

Anyway, we ended up in Edinburgh. Eventually. We toured the castle, and were walking down the hill where the touristy shops started, and I needed to further my quest for Scottish beers, which I really like. So a block and a half down, I see a little bar set below grade off in a narrow alley to the left. We walk in, and once my eyes adjusted to the darkness, OMG there easily had to be 300 bottles of Scotch in this place at the bar and on a high shelf that went all the way around the place.!

Silly me at the time, I asked for a beer, and the two guys behind the bar and the one customer there started laughing. The older one said: "Laddie, have ya any idea where ya arrrr?" All I could mutter sheepishly was "Scotch Mecca?" "Aye, indee(d). Now what do you want with yer beerrrr?" OK, I guess I'm going to have a Scotch! Correct answer!

So I figured, heck, might as well make it a good one, so I asked what I could get for L20 that was a good example, even then I knew rare ones were expensive. "Aye, tha'ull get ya a goodun." All thee were smiling, and I think they were actually pretty happy I went for something more rare. So the old guy pours a rather large shot out of an obviously older dusty bottle from the top bar shelf, along with my beer. Then they waited.

Holy freakin caddidlehoppers!!!!! I have absolutely no idea what I'd just drank, but wow it was intense!!! And I'm sure I reacted to it with surprise. I could still taste this stuff for the next six hours, and the aroma was in burps for a day!!! Possibly a cask strength, definitely smokey, extremely peaty (which I didn't understand at the time,) a huge iodine hit, rich, maybe a tad oily, a little salty, somewhat sweet, malt (I recognized that part!) and well, damn, SCOTCHY! I could swear it was like a 40 year old or something, but the memory of the name and details has faded away. "Now thot is a whisky, ma new friend!"

Dang, I wish I knew then what I know now!!! Perhaps I'll go back there some day; those guys may still be chuckling.
 
Thank you Akami, I will definitely head that direction.

Interesting Scotch-related story; you guys might like this. Back in about '96 I knew absolutely nothing about Scotch, and I was really starting to get into the continental beer, real ale and craft beer scene which was just starting at the time. The wife was a travel agent and we won a trip to England, so I was excited to try as many beers as I could. We took the kids over, and took the bullet train from London to Glasgow after a few days. Then we rented a car, attempting Inverness, but only made it as far as Fort William, which turned out to be very nice actually; driving there was a whole 'nother tale best told over a wee dram by a fire, though. Let's just say we're lucky to be alive, but we did see some of the most beautiful land on earth. Breathtaking in early spring!!!

Anyway, we ended up in Edinburgh. Eventually. We toured the castle, and were walking down the hill where the touristy shops started, and I needed to further my quest for Scottish beers, which I really like. So a block and a half down, I see a little bar set below grade off in a narrow alley to the left. We walk in, and once my eyes adjusted to the darkness, OMG there easily had to be 300 bottles of Scotch in this place at the bar and on a high shelf that went all the way around the place.!

Silly me at the time, I asked for a beer, and the two guys behind the bar and the one customer there started laughing. The older one said: "Laddie, have ya any idea where ya arrrr?" All I could mutter sheepishly was "Scotch Mecca?" "Aye, indee(d). Now what do you want with yer beerrrr?" OK, I guess I'm going to have a Scotch! Correct answer!

So I figured, heck, might as well make it a good one, so I asked what I could get for L20 that was a good example, even then I knew rare ones were expensive. "Aye, tha'ull get ya a goodun." All thee were smiling, and I think they were actually pretty happy I went for something more rare. So the old guy pours a rather large shot out of an obviously older dusty bottle from the top bar shelf, along with my beer. Then they waited.

Holy freakin caddidlehoppers!!!!! I have absolutely no idea what I'd just drank, but wow it was intense!!! And I'm sure I reacted to it with surprise. I could still taste this stuff for the next six hours, and the aroma was in burps for a day!!! Possibly a cask strength, definitely smokey, extremely peaty (which I didn't understand at the time,) a huge iodine hit, rich, maybe a tad oily, a little salty, somewhat sweet, malt (I recognized that part!) and well, damn, SCOTCHY! I could swear it was like a 40 year old or something, but the memory of the name and details has faded away. "Now thot is a whisky, ma new friend!"

Dang, I wish I knew then what I know now!!! Perhaps I'll go back there some day; those guys may still be chuckling.
Was in Edinburgh a few summers back for the Tattoo. I know the shops and pubs you're referring to. Lovely city.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OogieWaWa