• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Smooth Jazz is Jazz

I wonder if monster jazz players with a wealth of talent and chops sometimes tire of playing music that's mostly accessible to other monster musicians and a small percentage of the public. Maybe sometimes they'd rather play music that's more accessible to the average listener. I'm not talking about totally "dumbing it down," so to speak; I mean not always playing music that's too "out there" for most people.
This stereotype of jazz needs to die the same death as stereotypes about smooth jazz. Most jazz musicians are conscious of their audience, and interested in making music that their audiences will enjoy.

With that said, we can't all play the same stuff. The market for music that's absolutely guaranteed to satisfy everybody is utterly saturated, but is still only a fraction of the total addressable market for music. What it means is that some of us will play music that's Wrong in some way, ranging from experimental to offensive. We accept that we will have a smaller audience, but that the overall audience for music is bigger if there's more variety.
 
I never knew that and I have been listening to Sanborn most of my life.

Funny story related to listening to someone your whole life and not knowing it, and it relates to smooth jazz.

I was born in early 70s, so the "music bug" was kicking in for me in the late 70s, early 80s. One of my favorite songs growing up was (what I thought was a Bill Withers track), "Just the Two of Us," by Grover Washington Jr. I loved the intro especially because it had this dreamy quality, and what I was digging was the bass way up on the neck.

Fast forward to '88, and I start playing bass, and did the usual rock thing. Then played in a grunge band in college in the 90s. Discovered smooth jazz in '95, basically left rock/grunge almost for good, and that became my schtick.

Finally got around to buying Grover Washington Jr.'s "Winelight" on CD when the price for CDs began to nosedive as streaming took off, and Amazon was offloading CDs for like $5 USD, with free shipping. As an audiophile, I like having all the CDs, and rip them to FLAC on a Synology home server, and listen to them a lot like that. So I snagged Winelight; my old cassette copy was long gone by then, and I wanted the album. By this time, I've been playing bass for about 20 years, and knew all the bassists that bassists talk about. As I'm ripping it, I open the liner notes, and had to rub my eyes because there it was "Bass: Marcus Miller." I was like "WHAT? No wonder it's so good!"

I was a fan of Marcus for 30 years and didn't even know it. Ha ha
 
Funny story related to listening to someone your whole life and not knowing it, and it relates to smooth jazz.

I was born in early 70s, so the "music bug" was kicking in for me in the late 70s, early 80s. One of my favorite songs growing up was (what I thought was a Bill Withers track), "Just the Two of Us," by Grover Washington Jr. I loved the intro especially because it had this dreamy quality, and what I was digging was the bass way up on the neck.

Fast forward to '88, and I start playing bass, and did the usual rock thing. Then played in a grunge band in college in the 90s. Discovered smooth jazz in '95, basically left rock/grunge almost for good, and that became my schtick.

Finally got around to buying Grover Washington Jr.'s "Winelight" on CD when the price for CDs began to nosedive as streaming took off, and Amazon was offloading CDs for like $5 USD, with free shipping. As an audiophile, I like having all the CDs, and rip them to FLAC on a Synology home server, and listen to them a lot like that. So I snagged Winelight; my old cassette copy was long gone by then, and I wanted the album. By this time, I've been playing bass for about 20 years, and knew all the bassists that bassists talk about. As I'm ripping it, I open the liner notes, and had to rub my eyes because there it was "Bass: Marcus Miller." I was like "WHAT? No wonder it's so good!"

I was a fan of Marcus for 30 years and didn't even know it. Ha ha

:):):)
 
This is jazz yet one might describe it as smooth. Use of space, beautifully phrased, non cluttered etc. It is all there, though, a minimalist approach.

One of my very favorite jazz pieces...played it on trombone in a big band in the 70's...the harmonies in the arrangement were amazing. I can still sing my parts when I hear the tune, 45ish years later.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bassliner50
Sanborn plays out of the side of his mouth because he had polio as a child. He was in an iron lung for a year and took up the sax to help strengthen his mouth/throat/lungs.
Wow, did not know that (obviously), thank you for sharing that information.

It's mildly ironic/coincidental that the sax player in the video I posted played for Ian Dury, who also had polio as a child.
 
Funny story related to listening to someone your whole life and not knowing it, and it relates to smooth jazz.

Finally got around to buying Grover Washington Jr.'s "Winelight" on CD when the price for CDs began to nosedive as streaming took off... As I'm ripping it, I open the liner notes, and had to rub my eyes because there it was "Bass: Marcus Miller." I was like "WHAT? No wonder it's so good!"

I was a fan of Marcus for 30 years and didn't even know it. Ha ha
Similar story here. Marcus played on David Sandborn's Run For Cover, which I heard on the radio in the 80s. But I never knew anything about who played bass on that song. Over 30 years later, I decided to look up that song on YouTube. I only recognized it was Marcus because of his bass face (he does this thing with his lips) that I'd seen in other MM videos.
 
Duke Ellington said it is good if it sounds good.

An entire genre can’t be bad, or good.

There is extremely moving classical music and then there’s the sad repetitive opuses they play on rainy weekday afternoons on local classical stations. Some pieces done by the greats were commissioned for garden parties that week. Low on passion yet complete with all proper parts.

We all like different things. Only we know how moved we feel. Or not.
Yes some smooth jazz has earned the genre it’s reputation. There are horrific and trite applications of all the styles. I’ve seen a lot of mundane acts with all the best gear and lights. I’ve seen them eclipsed by four teens in a garage actually being a garage band. I’ve heard that garage band mean every note making the music for music’s sake.

Since we are the musicians can we commit to not calling it in but bringing it with big meaning?
 
As some have already said, I don't think there's a definitive line between "smooth" jazz and "real" jazz. Here's one that is pretty definitely "real" jazz (I mean, it's Joe Pass, ffs :)). But if I heard it on a smooth jazz station I think it would fit right in. Personally, I think this is sublime - it's not Joe's most complex playing, but so tasteful and toneful and melodic ... the "Intercontinental" album is my favorite Joe Pass, in fact.

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bass-ball