• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Struggling with a purchase decision.

Hey all. Hopefully this story won't be too long, I'll keep it as brief as possible.

I switched over to short scale basses some time ago (a year or two) because I'm small, and thought it would be more comfortable, which it is. But never been really happy with the sounds I get from them.

I'm itching for another long scale and am torn between the much revered squier vm jazz and the ibanez SR300. Seem to have quite similar necks but totally different beasts otherwise. The ibanez is a great light weight but doesn't have the massive tone of the jazz. And I find it horribly uncomfortable to play sitting down - I only play at home so am mostly seated anyway.

The jazz, although it sounds divine, and has an amazing feeling neck, is much heavier. Tried one out tonight and made my shoulder a bit sore after 10 mins. Thin nylon strap though, mine is wide and leather. I don't even play standing up much, but if that changes I may have trouble!

The one I tried also had a pretty high action due to a lot of relief, hopefully I could set it up to my liking assuming the truss rod hasn't been messed up. I'm scared of buying used basses.

Anyway. I'm really leaning towards the jazz as it sounded so good and I've itched for a jazz for a long time, but the weight and action are putting me off.

Help me talkbass, you're my only hope.

EDIT: the jazz is the seemingly very popular VM with satin neck and maple body
Ibby all the way, the dual humbucker set up has allowed me to get any sound i want. I go straight into an Ampeg and have learned to use the bass volume and tone controls. One thing i learned is to turn treble all the way down on the bass and then set my sound. I used to have many bass basses but after all the years i am down to 1. For small peeps, the neck is the best !! ps..i go from jazz to metal to motown...all in 1 bass
 
  • Like
Reactions: KickingBass
On a short scale the strings are looser. I tend to go a bit heavier on my short scale bass to keep the tension manageable, maybe itd fix your tone problem for you. Also, consider a pickup swap in a short scale, or adding a preamp to the signal. If you're mostly noodling around at home, I'd say get whatever you want. If you want to get out of the house to play, I'd say either go with the Ibanez or save up for a better shorty/upgrading your current axe.
 
I'd take an Ibanez over a Squier any day and its not because of the name on the headstock. I don't think I've ever held a Squier that didn't feel low quality and almost toyish. However Ive owned an Ibanez 305 and that definitely felt like quality. It's light but it felt sturdy and it was wonderfully light. My SR505 is just a little better and I think that says a lot.
 
I use Daddario nickels, super light gauge. I just want a good sound - not too thin but a bit of zing, punchy and thumpy but still clear. Warm and burpy :)


If you like your short scale bass
(playability/looks), maybe your problem is floppy strings? Try heavier gauge of your favorite strings (or another make/model altogether) and see how that goes in your current short scale before jumping to the long scale one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spirit of Ox
I loved my Ibanez (a LOT) and I love my jazzes, a lot. Over time I came to realize that I'm ultimately a passive bass guy, and a jazz guy. It's all preference, but from what I read in your post it sounds like you're a jazz guy too. Go Classic Vibe if you can, it's a better Squier jazz all-around than the VM, but I have one of each and they're both great. Passive vs active though is totally up to you, but I hated screwing with a battery. Nothing wrong with the passive tone either of course, and just about anything the preamp was doing I can do with a pedal or my amp, so...
 
I love Ibanez and Fender basses, but I was playing a song that required a deeper tone but with quite a bit of clarity - oddly enough, the bass that was capable of it was my Hohner headless bass. Full scale but small and yet has a deep sound.
I would also recommend trying out a Yamaha RBX170EW Mangowood (the tobacco is heavy) - it's passive and has the P/J pickup configuration. It's inexpensive, but has a pretty good sound. Also there are lighter Jazz bass options not just Fender or Squier, such as the Peavey Milestone.
Go with a p/j bass and you'll get the deeper sound than a jazz due to the P pickup.
 
I'd second the Aerodyne jazz bass. MIJs or CIJs can be had, from Japan, with shipping, used, for under $600 if you hold off for a deal. I've seen 3 go recently in the $400 range and then shipping. They look great with matching headstock, and they are light (basswood body). Check out how many good things people have to say about them.
 
What about an Aerodyne jazz? Full scale but light weight. Would depend on budget.

+1 on the Fender Aerodyne bass. I was going to mention that bass and Hrodbert beat me to it. Light weight, skinny, silky Jazz neck, jazz-profile basswood body is lightweight with big ton. It has a big range of tones, with P and J pups; sounds great throughout my usual range of reggae, blues, jazz.
 

Latest posts