• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Stupid Pickguard Poll!

What say ye?

  • Black! You only live once

    Votes: 72 59.0%
  • White! You should be practicing

    Votes: 33 27.0%
  • Orange! It's the color of, you know...

    Votes: 17 13.9%

  • Total voters
    122
Hows bout Orion Nebula (2)?!? :D

F4FB04B1-5837-4ABC-BA8E-48C65BF16400.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: alanloomis1980
White, parchment, mint green - all of those, under stage lighting, are gonna look pretty much the same. If you want people to see the pickguard (that's what they'll focus on under stage lighting) then keep it white or some variation. If you want them to see the wood, make the pickguard black, and their eyes will be drawn to the wood.

Odds are that people will watch your hands regardless, as that's what's moving, but it's a solid point that contrast is a big deal.

Generally I'm not a fan of tort, but I've seen a few brighter/more yellow sunbursts that look stunning with it, whereas darker bursts can tend to just look like a wash of brown to my eye - especially with rosewood pickguards.

In my own personal opinion the same goes for black - the tail of the pickguard can sometimes be lost against the darker outside edge. I personally like the shape of Precision style pickguards, so I like it accentuated - hence my love of lighter pickguards, but by the same token I feel like they look best on richer/darker bursts.

At any rate, as noted, nobody in the audience is going to be able to tell that I'm using a mint vs. white or parchment guard, but I really don't care that they don't care. I just care that my music moves them. These little aesthetic details are just for me! :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: alanloomis1980
Odds are that people will watch your hands regardless, as that's what's moving, but it's a solid point that contrast is a big deal.

Generally I'm not a fan of tort, but I've seen a few brighter/more yellow sunbursts that look stunning with it, whereas darker bursts can tend to just look like a wash of brown to my eye - especially with rosewood pickguards.

In my own personal opinion the same goes for black - the tail of the pickguard can sometimes be lost against the darker outside edge. I personally like the shape of Precision style pickguards, so I like it accentuated - hence my love of lighter pickguards, but by the same token I feel like they look best on richer/darker bursts.

At any rate, as noted, nobody in the audience is going to be able to tell that I'm using a mint vs. white or parchment guard, but I really don't care that they don't care. I just care that my music moves them. These little aesthetic details are just for me! :)
Yeah, I'm all about contrast. No bad colors, just bad combos! I think my perfect burst bass would have a black guard and a maple board. Overall, on that note, the white on mine meets that criteria.... but I've seen plenty of basses with burst-black-rosewood that still look pretty sweet!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kro