• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

SX Pino Palladino precision anyone?

bassgiant15 said:
I can't believe how close they are....well at least in looks!!!! Do the SX basses really sound good or just ok? I checked out that Rondo music site and was pretty impressed with their copies of popular basses.

Does anyone have an SX jazz bass or SX fretless and if so, how do they compare to Fenders in your opinion?


check out the sx megathread. its called essex so the search can grab it. The general consensus is that there the shiz tho.
 
Re: Essex (as an SX P bass owner) Here, I fixed it for you.

Joshua said:
Fill the holes that attach the p/up to the body, then re-drill some new strait holes so that the p/up can actually be raised and lowered and adjusted into the proper position so that a proper set up can be done, then Pop a high quality pickup in (heck, you might not even need to!), and you would for sure have a tough time telling the tone of the 2 basses apart...
 
bassgiant15 said:
I can't believe how close they are....well at least in looks!!!! Do the SX basses really sound good or just ok? I checked out that Rondo music site and was pretty impressed with their copies of popular basses.

Does anyone have an SX jazz bass or SX fretless and if so, how do they compare to Fenders in your opinion?

While I don't think it's fair to compare one bass manufacturer against another. Particularly one that is the standard by which all are judged (Fender) and one that clearly states that many of their instruments are starter models (SX), here's my take on the SX vs. Fender question.

I have an SX Jazz and an SX fretless (P-bass) and I love them both. In my opinion, the build quality is slightly below MIM Fenders. Though they usually need some setup right out of the box. Some even need fret leveling (though both of mine are fine).

Stock SXs and stock MIM Fenders are close (again in my opinion). If I had to rate them, the SX would be a very close second to a MIM Fender. Once an SX is modded however, they can hod their own with a MIM Fender any day.

My Jazz is modded (with Fender Noisless pups) and sounds great. Similar to a Fender sound. My fretless is stock. The unknown brand of P-bass type pups are a bit weak in the output department. But the bridge and tuners are solid. I will eventually change the pups and probably the bridge and pots as well.

The bottom line: an SX bass, for about half the price, is comparable to a MIM Fender in a lot of ways. But, it's not a Fender. It's a cheaper alternative that stands on its own pretty well. If you're thinking you can buy an SX and get a "cheaper" Fender forget it. SX is SX and Fender is Fender. SX basses are made in China and Korea and Fenders are made in the USA, Japan and Mexico, and elsewhere if you include Squier. Quality control varies in all these countries (even in the USA and Japan). Fender tries to maintain a certain standard with all its instruments (sometimes it succeeds, sometimes it doesn't). SX does too believe it or not. But Fender is a large company with many resources, Rondo Music is a small family owned business that makes low-end instruments. They are marketing to different audiences and their prices and quality reflect this.
 
Thanks for the info on the SX basses! I appreciate all the information on them. I have been thinking of buying one after hearing all the positive remarks (espcially a fretless, because i would be a noob on the fretless). I think that i am going to probably buy a good Fender and a cheap SX fretless.

I just wish i could try one out close to where i live just so that i could have my own opinion. :hmm:
 
Fender Japan now offers a Pino'esque P-bass now (model number is PB62-PP...which I gather stands for Pino Palladino), but I've only seen it on Japanese sites so it would likely have to be imported (not difficult):

[Invalid or Expired Link Removed]

[Invalid or Expired Link Removed]
 
DeanT said:
Here's a list of JD dealers. Presumable they sell the JD SX models as well.

Link Removed

well...you see, I called up a few of their dealers:

"hey, I was wondering if you sold any Jim Deacon basses"

"Jim Deacon?"

"Yeah"

"Erm....I havent heard them......"

"oh right, well your on their site as a dealer"

"Really?"

The idea of a dealer is somebody that actually sells the instrument right? :D
 
Some sites say they have a whole list of dealers, but this is just to cover up that they don't actually sell them, hardly anyone does. They might be selling them, but the shop won't even have any! Headstock similar to Fender? There is about 1000 identical headstocks to that as well matito.
 
DeanT said:
I have an SX Jazz and an SX fretless (P-bass) and I love them both. In my opinion, the build quality is slightly below MIM Fenders. Though they usually need some setup right out of the box. Some even need fret leveling (though both of mine are fine).

Stock SXs and stock MIM Fenders are close (again in my opinion). If I had to rate them, the SX would be a very close second to a MIM Fender. Once an SX is modded however, they can hod their own with a MIM Fender any day.

My Jazz is modded (with Fender Noisless pups) and sounds great. Similar to a Fender sound. My fretless is stock. The unknown brand of P-bass type pups are a bit weak in the output department. But the bridge and tuners are solid. I will eventually change the pups and probably the bridge and pots as well.

I see people say this here all the time and I have to disagree. Is it a great value for the price? Sure...if you like the stock setup. If not than take the money you would spend upgrading and buy a MIM Fender which I have found to be incredible values with no need to mod most of the time.

So by the list of things you listed and others ahve said need replaced...

Price of bass : $109
Pro setup with fret leveling $75
Pickup replacement: $60
Pots/Electronics: $10
Bridge: $15
Tuners: $40

By the end you have spent $309 so IMO you would ahve been better with a used MIM.

Again my opinion. More power to the SX lovers I think they are fine basses but I wanted to give a flipside opinion on the MIM comparison.
 
Actually I have yet to see an SX (although I have not touched a ton) that rivaled the MIM construction wise so I wouldn't buy the modded SX. That is just my opinion though.

Also resell is much better on the Fender. It would be very tough to get the extra $150 you spent on the SX back out of it. Where if I bought a used MIM I could get almost full used value out of it when I sold it.

I just am not one who believes in spending a ton on modding. I would rather take teh $150 I would spend modding and buy a better bass that didn't require it.
 
Stan_da_man said:
Well loads of people on this site would happily buy an SX including the extra mods at a higher price, I'm sure.

I've never seen an SX with mods go for more than the original price of the instrument. Maybe they do sometimes, but when the SX is so cheap to start with, most people will buy new and mod exactly as they see fit rather than pay extra for someone elses' idea of the perfect mod.