Sorry for the massive delay in getting back to you guys. I got tied up with kids and wife when I got home.
So, I went to see Carey today. Let me first say that Carey is such a nice guy. I mean really pleasant, didn't rush me, took his time and is just a great guy. Genuine and honest were things I kept thinking.
Stew on the other hand.

Nah! Stew was great too. Very quiet and calm demeanor. Very different from my type A personality. LOL
Just loved meeting these guys.
Carey took about an hour showing me stuff and talking to me about the pickups. He really took the time to explain the tonal differences between his NJ5's, the FatStacks, Big Single and the Big Splits.
Of all the pickups, I preferred the NJ5 Single Coils best. BUT, that is solo'd and not in my normal Modern Country enviro. THough I love them I think they'd be too aggressive in that type of supporting role.
I will say this though. Those are hands down the best Jazz pickup I have ever heard and man were they aggressive. Very growly and forward. Lots of bite. If that is your thing BUY A SET ASAP!
I saw and heard Tom's bass with the Fat Stacks. Very nice. I played Carey's Sherwood Green VJ5 with the Big Splits. That seems to be the ticket I think for me. More forward and biting than the Fat Stacks but still big and full. It should paly the supporting role well and at the same time provide great definition and punch to the notes.
I took my Sadowsky Ash/Maple PJ5 for Carey to check out. He dug the tone.
I am still shocked at the weight of the VJ5's. Both of my PJ5's weight right around 8.5 - 8.75 lbs. Perfect for me. Both are chambered bodies. Carey's VJ5 is not chambered, full size jazz and still weighed about the same. That just shocked me.
Only downside I se right now, and this is just a personal thing, is the neck width and profile. I guess my hands arent' as small as I thought because Carey's necks are thinner and a hair narrower than the Sadowsky 5er necks and I think I prefer the bigger Sadowsky neck.
We'll see. Carey was kind enough to let me borrow HIS Shwerwood Green VJ5 for a week or so to see if it'll work for me. I hope it does because that is the ONLY CON I can find.
The fit and finish is amazing. He showed me a Candy Apple Red 5er like Toms (with all the knobs) and I could not find a flaw anywhere on it. Just amazing. And no, it wasn't done by Pat Wilkins. That surprised me too.
I found out that the preamp I heard in the J5 at the Bass Exchagne was the OBP-3 and NOT the Audere. That madea lot of sense because I do not like the Aguilar preamps at all.
I heard the Audere and it is very nice. Like Carey points out, it sound like your passive tone just boosted. There isn't that high end push that you get froom some preamps. I liked it a lot.
Got to hear Carey's preamp and really liked that as well. Defintely a winner so far. Very rich tone. We also discussed some other "Nordstrand" preamp possibilities but I will let Carey talk about that if he goes forward.
We talked about his P5 pickup afeter hearing the Sadowsky P. I was happy to hear what he said about its tone. I didn't get to hear one but I am intrigued to hear what it sounds like.
So as of right now it is a "let's see if I can play this neck" thang. I have bad tendinitis and today my left hand was aching. Makes me play like crap. (Thanks for not laughing to hard Carey and Stew).
I will say this though. The necks are incredibly fast and very solid. Like I said, for me it'll just be a matter of if I will be comfortable playing a neck that is a lot thinner than the Sadowsky necks.
We'll see over the next week. If it works for me, I may be ordering a PJ5 Reversed P and a VJ5 with Big Splits. Preamp? Not sure right now. My heart still lies with that sadwsky tone so my first option is the Sadowsky pre. BUT that Audere and Carey's sounded great too. We'll see.
Gary - Didn't see your bass man.
Here is Carey's bass he let me borrow. What a guy.
Link Removed