With the introduction of the Elementary, I'm not sure if I should go for an Elementary or a UA for my November order. I know everyone is just gonna say 'Get Both' and I very well may do that eventually, but it probably wont be for quite some time due to financial availability and board space. It will be utilized on a board that get's used for both bass and guitar.... thoughts?
I don't have an Elementary (yet!), but I do have a DW and a UA. All the standard caveats apply: my rig, my basses, ymmv, etc. Relevant parts of the signal chain are MTD 535 or MM Stingray fretless for the most part > Accountant compressor, set to be a dirty boost > Jive, no diodes, gain up to get some mid grind, volume at just over unity > MBD2 > SV-Pre > UA > DW > Omnicomp > RFE > Aggie TH700 (lately just plugging into the FX return) > Acme or Avatar 2x10, or PJB 27. I'm using the three preamps in an 'either-or' configuration, i.e., not stacked.
I use the UA for more of a vintage, less modern tone. Gain up around noon, master at unity, bass and treble just north of noon, mids just backed off of max, maybe 4 o'clock. Gives me a warm, wooly, edge-of-breakup tone that doesn't get harsh or buzzy. Bottom end is just bloomy enough to feel expressive. Enough mids to be articulate, but well 'sat' in the mix. Still running the stock JJ 12AX7. It responds well to either of my two boosts; the Accountant adds its own distortion, that blends really well with the mild overdrive of the UA; the Jive just adds more body, and pushes the tube a little harder. The UA also tames the brightness from the MBD2, and the added Depth from the MBD can add a lot (sometimes too much) billowy bottom.
I'm running the DW for more of a modern clean sound. Big round bottom, clean glassy highs. It's very present. I swapped V1 for a 5751, and may go to a 12AU7 there, and move the 5751 to V2; there is a
lot of volume available. Gain is at 9, Master at unity, Bass and Treble around noon, mids about 3. Also responds well to the boosts and MBD2, though with the gain low, it doesn't break up much. The MBD2 can be a bit strident, but a twist of the tone knob fixes that. My guitar player (an absolute tone hound) was really impressed with my tone on an R&B tune (Lizzo - About Damn Time) we just started doing. I think the DW fits that really well.
The SV-Pre is for all the mid-boosted, grindy stuff.
With these three preamps, plus the Aggie preamp, (when it gets used), gives me just about any tone I could need.
So, yeah, buy 'em both