• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Thunderbird Club

Here we go.
Played the same riff finger-style first, then pick-style.
Tried to play as consistent as possible on both recordings.

https://www.brooksbassguitars.com/uploads/1/3/3/7/13376708/test_ey_vs_gibson_-_a.mp3

and

https://www.brooksbassguitars.com/uploads/1/3/3/7/13376708/test_ey_vs_gibson_-_b.mp3


May I have your votes please
To my ears, playing thru my iPad speaker (horrible way to test bass pickups) I’d say the second sound sample was warmer and rounder on the bottom end and more musical (cleaner, better definition) on the top end with the mid range about the same as the first sample.

So I’m going to lean towards the first sample being the EY pickup and the second sound sample being the Gibson pickup.
 
Another observation in regards to EY pickups - in my experience I found them to be relatively nice pickups especially for their price. That said, I also found them slightly lacking in bottom end (vs Gibson TB+ or Eppi ProBuckers) when only one pickup is used, but that lack of broad range content went away as a second or third pickup was added. So my advice, EY pickups aren’t a great option on a Tbird II build (go with a ProBucker or Gibson pickup instead), but on a IV build where you can dial in a second pickup to round out the tone the EY pickups are a perfectly good and low cost option. Just my two cents.
 
I get it. It’s all personal preference. What cracks me up are the threads in the GP asking for an amp, other than Ampeg, that they can get to dial in the Ampeg tone. Just buy a freaking Ampeg.
Now that I'll agree with. Buy a Chevy Volt so it'll drive like a Porsche.:eyebrow::rollno:
 
There's no comparison..... Way more going on with Gibsons, I've already done it.
Would you like some EYs cheap? :D
George is graciously going to give me some of his time this Sunday to help install the Gibson in the BaCH II. And I now have a set of the 760 Probuckers in the VP with the broken neck that came last week. So I’m set thanks.
IMG_3189.jpeg
 
Here we go.
Played the same riff finger-style first, then pick-style.
Tried to play as consistent as possible on both recordings.

https://www.brooksbassguitars.com/uploads/1/3/3/7/13376708/test_ey_vs_gibson_-_a.mp3

and

https://www.brooksbassguitars.com/uploads/1/3/3/7/13376708/test_ey_vs_gibson_-_b.mp3


May I have your votes please
Going back and listening with headphones, the second clip didn't sound as dark and the first set was thinner. Which I guess indicates what is being played through can make almost as much difference as the pickup itself. Said Capt. Obvious. Kind of like playing at home verses a big room makes things sound very different.
 
George is graciously going to give me some of his time this Sunday to help install the Gibson in the BaCH II. And I now have a set of the 760 Probuckers in the VP with the broken neck that came last week. So I’m set thanks.
View attachment 5210814

You'll need to shim it up at least as much as the height of the pickup, I cut and glued one made of Mahogany for mine.
 
Going back and listening with headphones, the second clip didn't sound as dark and the first set was thinner. Which I guess indicates what is being played through can make almost as much difference as the pickup itself. Said Capt. Obvious. Kind of like playing at home verses a big room makes things sound very different.
I listened on headphones-only way I can hear my desktop-but ya gots to remember, my hearing sux.
 
You'll need to shim it up at least as much as the height of the pickup, I cut and glued one made of Mahogany for mine.

Seems like this is a thing on all of my Gibson IV’s at the bridge when going with vintage style metal covered pups in place of TB+ style. Some of mine the pickup is just about completely out of the cavity. Good thing I’ve come to like the trim rings!
 
Seems like this is a thing on all of my Gibson IV’s at the bridge when going with vintage style metal covered pups in place of TB+ style. Some of mine the pickup is just about completely out of the cavity. Good thing I’ve come to like the trim rings!
I was thinking about making a router table template for the spacer. Might be sketchy actually routing the piece though - have to give that some thought.