LOL - “From the moment I set it in my lap I experienced that neck dive that Thunderbirds are so famous for”
So in other words, he NEVER strapped it on with a bass strap while standing. He’s just spewing his bias and preconceived opinions. In fact he goes on to say, “Gibson, why do you hate bass players so much” which I read as a general comment on Gibsons entire bass line up, not just specifically the one model he held.
Just for S&Gs I pulled out my NR BaCH and yep she’s a diver when I set it in my lap, unless I rest my right forearm on the body (like I do with all my basses). Then I pulled out my Reverse Tbirds, same neck dive in lap story, but none of them dive while strapped on. So I figured, must be the lower bout cutout location that rests on you thigh, maybe it’s better on a FSO. So I pulled out some Jazz and P and Tele basses, and every single one of them neck dives in my lap just as much as my birds.
I will agree with him on fit and finish - a $2000 bass shouldn’t have glaring F&F issues like fret sprout, raised frets, obvious paint blems etc. Don’t know if the one he tried had those issues, and if it did, if thats common across the model, or if its just one bad one or possibly Blem stock being sold on the store floor. Folks that have bought these can chime in, but I don’t recall hearing horror stories about bad frets, bowed necks, and the like from the users here.
Set up is a whole different story and shouldn’t be lumped in with defects or workmanship or quality control, it’s a personal thing. When I get a new bass that’s set up nicely for me right out of the box, I think cool that saves me some time. But when it comes with the action too high or the pups too low, etc. I just pull out the tools and get it to where I want it, no big deal.