Hey everybody. After much debate on what to get for my first double bass, I visited the Mystic store and made the decision to buy an Upton Standard Laminate. Unfortunately there is a 6 month wait but the excitement for it will probably kill me before the wait does. When I was there placing the order, I did not specify which pickup I wanted. From what I heard I liked the Revolution Solo the best and it is what I'm leaning towards. What do you guys use, and if it is the RS how is it in a gig setting? Is it loud enough without feedback and how does it sit in a mix? Thanks!
Congrats on ordering your new UB Standard Laminate! I received mine in April of 2016 (first upright for me) and have been loving it.
I bought the Realist Lifeline pickup, based on testimonials and referrals. I'm in an area where there are no real bass shops within several hours' drive, so I couldn't test out anything for myself. The Lifeline works pretty well (about as well as any pickup CAN), but can tend to sound a bit 'quacky' at times - a pronounced mid-range 'thwack' with each pizzicato pluck. Sometimes EQing or reversing the phase on my preamp (ALiX) helps a little. But it's always there.
I was always curious about the Revolution Solo, but have never used one. From the demo videos, it seems like it is a little more adjustable (after installation) than the Lifeline, allowing for tweaking of the desired sound. Once the Lifeline is installed, you can't really move/adjust it without loosening the string tension to take the pressure off of the bridge.
There is a great YouTube video (in German, unfortunately) that compares about a dozen upright pickups and mics, all mounted on the same bass at the same time, for a more 'apples to apples' comparison:
Invalid Link Removed
Obviously, many things will affect your live sound, in addition to your pickup - your technique, strings, preamp, amp, speaker cab, room, type of music, size/style of ensemble, etc. So, what works for one person may not work for another. I'm sure others will chime in here with their experiences, also.