I wanted to like the badwater because the sound demos sounded decent and I had a walrus deep6 comp that I’ve loved. I got the badwater as soon as I could And then returned it as quick as I could.
compared to other amp sim pedals I’ve used it is a bit noisier. But more than that imo it just wasn’t good sounding. The mids were kinda bland there wasn’t that much of the finer things I seek in tone.
This is nothing against metal dudes but I think it would work well for heavier rock to metal. But the metal dudes I know would still go for the Darkglass products.
For me I look for a big warm sounding clean tone with breakup as you play harder. Also, when you change the EQ the character of the breakup should change, With the Bw It didn’t.
Imo,The BW just sounded like a “canned” /“synthetic” sounding bass grit pedal. Almost like you’re in garage band, recorded your bass straight in then clicked a button that said “Drive” then you tried adjusting the eq and it still sounded the same.
I’ve had a bunch of walrus pedals that I’ve loved and still love. The Badwater didn’t do it for me.
I’ve had the Microtubes vintage, don’t have it anymore but that’s a pedal I still think about. It’s awesome!
I currently have the Origin SV and haven’t really looked back.