• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What I wish Fender would make...

023.jpg
merican which this one

The Best Solution I have found although not cheap
(if you want American that is) and not "P" although they have covered all the other basses rather well I would say including that annoying truss rod issue. Personally I like the Jazz PU config better, more versatile (Just ask Geddy)
 
5 string basses with a 12" or flatter fingerboard radius, with a thin neck profile (both width-wise and front-to-back).

Hah!

5 string basses with a 9.25" or rounder fingerboard radius, with a thin neck profile (both width-wise and front-to-back).

We all have our preferences, eh?!

The 5 string Aerodyne P/J is on my gas list. I'm just not a fan of the Jazz body style.

(Also, @Matthew_84, you should check out the Bacchus basses. I was SUPER impressed with everything about the 5 I bought. But I sold it because the radius was just too flat. My hand simply couldn't get comfortable--but the neck was wicked fast, the tone was solid from the bottom to the top, and the fit and finish were unbelievable for the price.)
 
Hah!

5 string basses with a 9.25" or rounder fingerboard radius, with a thin neck profile (both width-wise and front-to-back).

We all have our preferences, eh?!

The 5 string Aerodyne P/J is on my gas list. I'm just not a fan of the Jazz body style.

(Also, @Matthew_84, you should check out the Bacchus basses. I was SUPER impressed with everything about the 5 I bought. But I sold it because the radius was just too flat. My hand simply couldn't get comfortable--but the neck was wicked fast, the tone was solid from the bottom to the top, and the fit and finish were unbelievable for the price.)
Thanks for the tip! Will do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Elkins
So you want an inexpensive mass-produced custom instrument?
My Luthier would disagree with you! He HATES allen wrench truss rod adjusters. The big fat screw on the heel of the neck is a way better (i.e. less easy to mess up) method.

I honestly don't think it's that big of a problem...I mean....how often to you adjust the relief on your neck?

Fender does need to change the nut end, they can keep using the big fat screw, just dig a damn hole in the body so we can use a screwdriver! no rocket science, taking the neck off every four months is a big pain.

Everybody other brand: turn the truss rod, tune bass, check relief, adjust if needed.

Fender " vintage correct": take the strings off, take the neck off, adjust the truss rod, put the neck back, put strings, tune, check relief, if adjustment needed, take the strings off, take the neck....

Of course your tech is happy, that means more customers for him, who will need a luthier to adjust the truss rod in a Stingray.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fat Steve
Fender does need to change the nut end, they can keep using the big fat screw, just dig a damn hole in the body so we can use a screwdriver! no rocket science, taking the neck off every four months is a big pain.

Everybody other brand: turn the truss rod, tune bass, check relief, adjust if needed.

Fender " vintage correct": take the strings off, take the neck off, adjust the truss rod, put the neck back, put strings, tune, check relief, if adjustment needed, take the strings off, take the neck....
Yeah....I see your point...just making it more accessible by a route would work for those of us who have pick guards. I'm surprised you have to adjust your relief every four months! Mine is like a Ronco Rotisserie....set it, and forget it!
 
This is a pure business decision... Many Fender players own a P and a J bass. If Fender offered a MIA or even a good MIM PJ bass some Fender players would be content to only own that bass.

So it would be stupid for Fender to make a product that a lot of people would buy, because it would cannibalize sales of their other products. Because the customer is always right except when it might hurt quarterly results.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fat Steve
especially since most people want the j for only that bridge pu for the jaco type of stuff.

Not true for me. I like the way a P/J sounds and you can make it sound like a P bass. I don't think I've ever solo'd any bridge pickup. Have always used P/J's full up or blended toward the P. But that is a personal preference thing. Some people don't care for that sound, some love it.

I agree with the buy different basses for different situations logic because I'll take any justification to have more basses. That being said, for most long haul gigs I bring a two pickup five string just to cover as many bases (basses???) as possible. That's why I think a five string P/J is a great bass to have.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bdplaid
So it would be stupid for Fender to make a product that a lot of people would buy, because it would cannibalize sales of their other products. Because the customer is always right except when it might hurt quarterly results.

No it's stupid to make a great product that lots of MIA buyers would buy instead. Hence the smart money makes a bass that a lot of people would buy and then slaps a "Squier" sticker on the headstock to insure that no MIA buyer would ever consider buying one! Win-Win!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bunk McNulty
i read all the posts to make sure someone mentioned.....





































TELECASTER BASS!!!


that's what i want bad! simple as can be but one with a big fat neck. you know, a bass an upright player would like.

a non-short-scale coronado with a fat neck would be nice too.
 
Fender does need to change the nut end, they can keep using the big fat screw, just dig a damn hole in the body so we can use a screwdriver! no rocket science, taking the neck off every four months is a big pain.

Everybody other brand: turn the truss rod, tune bass, check relief, adjust if needed.

Fender " vintage correct": take the strings off, take the neck off, adjust the truss rod, put the neck back, put strings, tune, check relief, if adjustment needed, take the strings off, take the neck....

Of course your tech is happy, that means more customers for him, who will need a luthier to adjust the truss rod in a Stingray.

See my last post. You don't have to take the neck off.