• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What pickup configuration/tone do you find most useful?

What pickup configuration/tone do you find most useful?

  • 2 Jazz bass pickups

  • 1 Precision bass pickup

  • 1 Musicman bass pickup

  • Dual soapbars

  • P +J

  • P +P

  • P +MM

  • Mm+Mm


Results are only viewable after voting.
I play Spirit Steinberger copies, five strings with ancient flats. These basses have two soapbar passive EMGs. I've found my set-it-and-forget-it sound by simply diming both pickups, as well as the tone knob. Outboard gear takes care of the rest, whether live or recording.

Aesthetically I prefer the look and vibe of single pickup instruments. But my ears tell me to definitely use both pickups on these instruments.
 
Indecisive? Maybe on an active bass with lots of knobs. On a simple Jazz Bass setup, the choice of pickup(s) is an easy and one-time decision for me - whichever fits the song best. Then each time I play the song, I use the same configuration. 2 pickups is my favorite for covering multiple tones.
 
2 multicoils with a filter preamp.

cb-basses.jpeg
 
Versatilitiy isn't needed if your one pickup sounds great. I'd say versatility often is a crutch. You think you need it, but you don't, and it just makes you indecisive.
The "do one great sound" approach is valid, I've got basses like that, sure. But I prefer max versatility, myself. Why settle for just one great sound? Sure, not every setting is a great sound for widespread use, but still can be useful for special cases. My bass shouldn't sound the same when I'm covering the Stones' version of "Poison Ivy" vs Vanilla Fudge's "You Keep Me Hanging On", or anything King Crimson.

A Bowie knife can be very useful. So can a Swiss Army knife multitool. "Any tool is a weapon, if you hold it right." ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mastermold
I think you should have also included P/J configuration in your voting list? I love the P Bass sound solo’ed, but my favourite and go to sound at the moment is on my Player Plus in Active mode but slightly favouring the Jazz pickup and with the bass boosted.
 
I find two jazz pickups to be the configuration that works best for me in the most situations. This is not related to the versatility of having different combinations of those two pickups available, though... when it comes to gigging and recording I nearly always use both pickups full-on. I enjoy a good P bass and have my own that I enjoy playing (mostly at home), but at least for me the j setup is the one that works the best in the most mixes for the stuff I tend to play.