Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
What's all the hype about these SD Quarter Pounders???
- Thread starter Bassman1905
- Start date
)
The hype is that some people like them and others do not. I have a pair in my HW1 P-Bass and don't care much for them. They overdrive the input on my amp and I don't like that. Yes, I can turn down the input gain, but I still don't like it. Anyway, I have fallen in like with the DP122 since then. The QPs will be coming as as soon as I get around to it. Give 'em a shot though, they are relatively inexpensive.
Jo6Pak and some others don't like them. I and many others do like them.
I have one in my 78 P bass and it's wonderful- with Thomastic flatwounds- through any good amp I use--currently a GK.
They have a bit more output and aggressive sound than some other P pickups due in part to their 1/4" pole pieces and extra windings, but they also can be easily tamed down to work with any kind of music. A lot depends on how close to the strings you adjust them. They don't overdrive my amp at all.
I much prefer them to the stock pickup and to a Dimarzio I also had in that bass.
Anyhow, try a bass that has them and see if you like it. You'll never get any real idea of their sound by asking others.
I have one in my 78 P bass and it's wonderful- with Thomastic flatwounds- through any good amp I use--currently a GK.
They have a bit more output and aggressive sound than some other P pickups due in part to their 1/4" pole pieces and extra windings, but they also can be easily tamed down to work with any kind of music. A lot depends on how close to the strings you adjust them. They don't overdrive my amp at all.
I much prefer them to the stock pickup and to a Dimarzio I also had in that bass.
Anyhow, try a bass that has them and see if you like it. You'll never get any real idea of their sound by asking others.
I bought a Fender Mustang for a rock show and the pickup's in that bass sucked big time. But not because they were 'ordinary' sounding pups, but because I was comparing them to the pups in my Fender P basses. I got on line, read a mountain of reviews on harmony central and went with SD Quarter Pounders. They made all the difference. Then I was offered a set of Tone Riders and they were just as good. So my experience tells me that those pickups will make a difference to your $300 bass but they might not make it sound like a $2000 bass. If they did, manufactureres of $300 basses would be paying the extra dollars to have them fitted and making a retail killing.
bongomania
Commercial User
Another thing is that the QP's are a bit scooped in the mids compared to other P pups. If you are after a boom-click tone then they are pure gold, but if you are after a vintage fat-mids tone they will disappoint.
I agree, I had them in my Jazz and your tone will get buried unless mids are added at the amp. They are OK, I think people just like the name quarter-pounder!
500k pot sounds interesting i have a squier and these are in them i wonder where to get a 500k pot and how much for and how much of a difference sound like something id like to experiment with...
That's certainly not true in my case and in a few other basses I've heard with the QP. I hate the "boom-click" tone and like plenty of mids and not too much highs. But I keep hearing that same old statement.
Nobody I've played with has ever said my P bass doesn't sound great or that it's mid scooped or doesn't sound like a P bass should. They like the way it sounds live and on record, so it's not just me. Other bass players like it too.
I had a set on my '99 Ash/Rosewood P and liked them a lot. Much louder output then the originals. Replaced them with a set of SPB-2 Hot Stack which I am liking a little better, less agressive and warmer P tone....
My experience has been a little different.
I have a set in my Geddy Lee, and I play tapewounds on it. People always comment on my tone. A couple of weeks ago, I was asked to sit in for a set with a band and used the bassist's Super Redhead. He said he was amazed by the tone I was getting and asked what type of special work I had done to my bass. He'd been playing for 30 years. When I told him it was just Quarter Pounders and tapewounds, he couldn't believe it.
So, depending upon how you're set up, QPs can make a big difference for the positive.
I have a set in my Geddy Lee, and I play tapewounds on it. People always comment on my tone. A couple of weeks ago, I was asked to sit in for a set with a band and used the bassist's Super Redhead. He said he was amazed by the tone I was getting and asked what type of special work I had done to my bass. He'd been playing for 30 years. When I told him it was just Quarter Pounders and tapewounds, he couldn't believe it.
So, depending upon how you're set up, QPs can make a big difference for the positive.
ding ding ding ding
I had a Quarter Pounder P-bass pickup in an SX heavy mod project and I was never fond of the pickup. It was always to scooped in my opinion.
But I've said that before and other have been greatly offended that I think a Quarter Pounder is scooped sounding.
:: shrug ::
.
it could also be the type of music your band plays. I could see them work quite well in a blues/jazz settings where you don't need as much midrange as in a rock band with crunchy guitars
I've used them and I like them. They are a fine p'up for not much money. They are *much* beefier sounding than the stock Fender p'ups.
ebay, allparts, wdmusic etc... just search 500k pots.
i got fender 500k pots. i had to make some room in the cavity because i got the full size ones, totally worth it for me.
They definitely helped my $300 bass: an Ibanez SR810.
The stock pickups and preamp had no personality, and were as sterile as it gets! The sweepable midrange helped, but I usually left the eq flat.
Now the bass has a Quarter Pounder P in the middle, and a J in the bridge. All passive, vol/vol/tone with a 3 way selector. Its very lively now!
The stock pickups and preamp had no personality, and were as sterile as it gets! The sweepable midrange helped, but I usually left the eq flat.
Now the bass has a Quarter Pounder P in the middle, and a J in the bridge. All passive, vol/vol/tone with a 3 way selector. Its very lively now!
i've got a set of SPB-3's that need to go to a new home
all it takes is a phillips screwdriver & a soldering iron & you can judge the tone for yourself
all it takes is a phillips screwdriver & a soldering iron & you can judge the tone for yourself
