• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

When is your bass "good enough"?

What does it take for you to be happy with your bass? Is it tone, playability or aesthetics? Share and explain your bass mods here.

  1. Playability/Ergonomics
  2. Sound
  3. Looks
The tone can be changed with via string choice and electronics changes. Shoddy tuners or bridge can be replaced. How it feels and plays is forever, or at least harder to change.

I tend to be entirely uninterested in a bass if the ergonomics aren't there. That's why I gravitated to Fender Jazz style basses early with my Warmoth, then to an MTD Kingston after trying one at a shop and just falling in love with the neck and weight and balance.

Once the physicality is sorted, I'm an electronics tinkerer until I get the sound I want. That and my physics degree explains my high participation in the Pickups and Electronics forum here.

I tend to tinker on the electronics for a short while then settle for the life of the instrument.

GAS and Mods-wise, I just did the math!
On average, a preamp will live in one of my basses for 7 years.
On average, a pickup set will live in one of my basses for 6.5 years.
I have only ever owned 5 basses, 3 of which I still own. (fretted, fretless, acoustic)
I'm not as bad as I thought I was!
 
  • Like
Reactions: twinjet
Hello TB,

A question regarding modifications. Most of us enjoy making our basses our own, whether it's a neck swap or preamp install. Some of us only want one or two things done, some go the whole nine yards and completely renovate their instrument.

What does it take for you to be happy with your bass? Is it tone, playability or aesthetics? Share and explain your bass mods here.

As someone who has altered and customized more basses over the years than I care to recall, here is how I handle modifications now...I buy an off the shelf Music Man and I'm done with it. At some point enough is enough.
 
My jazz is almost there. It needs some more fretwork, still catching me when moving the left hand. Once those fangs get knocked back I'll have it. Looks and sounds the way I want, one last issue with feel setup is otherwise great.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    113.6 KB · Views: 31
What would replacing a plastic nut with a graphite nut do for a bass?

Graphite is inherently slippery (it's a primary ingredient in a number of off-the-shelf lubricants), so a nut infused with it won't create as much drag on your strings while adjusting the tuning. Some people, myself included, will doodle a little pencil lead into the nut slots to get similar results. Fun, related fact…most pencils don't use lead anymore. Instead, they use…drumroll pleaseGRAPHITE! :jawdrop: :D
 
I think there's something to modding a standard production bass to make it a little more original.

I did a mixture of cosmetic and electronic mods on a $300 bass to make it more 'mine' and am happy with the result. On my other bass, I've made some adjustments for playability and intonation (not that these would be considered mods), and I made a tiny, easily reversible mod to raise some of the pickup pole pieces, and I dulled the gloss off the back of the neck (that probably does qualify as a mod).

It's all about optimizing an instrument for playability, tone, and aesthetics. Some basses may invite more tinkering than others. Plus (assuming things don't go awry!), it can be pretty fun.
 
That, sir, is very quotable. I might have to steal that one from you. :thumbsup:

By all means, go right ahead! :oops: All I ask is for credit to be given when it's due, like any proper reporter or author would. If so, I'll give your avatar an apple!

I think there's something to modding a standard production bass to make it a little more original.

…to make it a little more "YOU", perhaps? ;) :thumbsup:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rickter
Generally, I try to buy for playability and looks, and mod for tone. My "good enough" point is the tonal ballpark I'm aiming for, where I can get it the rest of the way using technique changes. Usually different strings is all it takes, but I'd swap out a pickup and electronics if necessary. I don't obsess over the details that I have found to be less significant (e.g. bridge ime has a negligible impact on tone).

But looking at the entire process of my gear buying and modding, I tended to gravitate towards simplicity. To me, good enough went from "what can I add or upgrade to make it better" to "what can I remove or simplify to eliminate what is unnecessary and distracting". Right now, I'm quite happy with a P-bass :)
 
I don't do "good enough". It pleases me or it doesn't. Good enough sounds like it barely please so I know I won't be satisfied ... I put more money toward something that I want more instead of going with the less expense be "good enough"

The price must be right for my perceived value of the thing, the shape must please me, number of strings, easy to play, little details like no fret will one day sprout on the edge of the neck,

+1.