I have been playing bass only a couple of years, but I experienced 2 gaps in playing guitar:
- played 5-6 years seriously at the beginning (heavy band playing and studying with teachers all this time)
- stopped for 5-6 years
- played seriously another 4-5 years (band playing but no teachers)
- stopped for 12-13 years
- played lightly in the last 2-3 years (no band)
When I say "stopped" I mean barely touching the instrument at all, no more than a couple times
a year.
Both times I restarted, I was surprised by how much technique I retained. It felt a bit like riding a bike or downhill skiing, you never really forget how to do it, but of course you can't expect to jump back to the same performance level, some of my rhythm feel was out of shape, and my fastest licks had become noisy. But still, it doesn't take that long to get back to that either if you want.
What I did lose though, was the repertoire: almost all the songs I used to play were gone from my memory. I could recall the most difficult ones (probably because I spent more time practicing them) by trying to let my hands go without thinking
If you developed any bad habits previously, now would be the perfect time to correct them before moving forward.
Absolutely! After my first gap of 5 years, I really took the chance to rewire myself to play as effortlessly as possible. I had been reading Jamies Andreas articles and book about this topic, and I knew I was a very tense and aggressive player before, so I consciously worked to fix that when restarting and really changed my way playing.
I was surprised by how much came back to me pretty quickly
I just went back to familiar songs and started there, kind of re-learning/remembering them. The muscle memory was there; I just need to blow away the cobwebs a bit and oil my creaky joints.
It honestly didn't take me that long to get back into the swing of things. I don't play as aggressively as I did way back when, but that's fine. I'm much older now and would rather work on dialing back and refining my playing. Getting back into the pocket was really just a matter getting dexterity and muscle memory back into my hands.
Glad to hear your experience on bass mirrors mine on guitar!
All the theory is still in my head, and I listened to a lot of great music while I didn't play.
Good point, I forgot about theory! I also remembered it easily but honestly I always loved music theory and I had been reading some of it even during those gaps
