• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Which Should I get?

Which should I get?

  • Rickenbacker 4003s

    Votes: 75 36.1%
  • Pedulla Pentabuzz

    Votes: 133 63.9%

  • Total voters
    208
I've never been a fan of Rics for several reasons, on of the main ones being the sharp angle at the edges of the fretboard. However, I've always loved the mwaaahhh factor of Pedullah fretless basses. So, take what I post with a grain of salt. BTW, where's the 'carrots" option?
 
550C19F1-1A2B-469A-9391-014577DAAC43.jpeg
550C19F1-1A2B-469A-9391-014577DAAC43.jpeg
53874AAA-5585-47A0-8074-045A026087CC.jpeg


These are shots of the trussrod. I cannot tell if it is stripped or not. The bass is quite playable, but it slightly frets out at 21 frets with some buzz, but it is still playable.
 
View attachment 2825920


Last summer, I found a Pedulla Pentabuzz at a great deal, and laid it away. All went well, but then it appeared that Illinois might renege on medical and dental bills of state employees. I eventually bailed on the layaway because it looked like I was going to have to pay some bills.

A month or two later, the good folks in Springfield found a few billion to pay off doctors, and the Pentabuzz is still around, and I was planning to pick it up for Birthday in February.

The thing that has got me rethinking everything is that last summer, I replayed a Rickenbacker 4003s, a bass very similar to my first good bass, a Ric 4000. I have to admit the Ric feels like home, even though it has been thirty years, and I am thinking maybe limited funds would be better spent on a bass I know for a fact I would love instead of spending a year really getting a thorough handle on fretless?





DR. Cheese I voted Pedulla
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. Cheese
I am bit conflicted because I have good relations with the pawn shop, and from an ethical standpoint, I hate going back on my word twice. My main problem is that oldest is going to college in two years, and this will be my last window for a major bass purchase before I have to contribute to my child’s higher education. What I don’t buy now, I cannot get for maybe seven years.
I have two in Universities now, so I feel your pain Dr. C I can only dream of my next bass and at a major discounted price point so far I have nothing really tearing at me gear wise thankfully :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. Cheese
Officially and in accordance with TalkBass tradition of spending other player's money for them, I say "Both!!!" but if I were in your shoes I'd have bought the Pedulla yesterday. The Rick is a great bass but you can find them any day of the week in almost any major market and price point. The Pedulla, while definitely a time-stamped bass within our community, is still an incredible instrument and a comparatively much rarer bird to come across.

I'd also mention that if you buy the Pedulla and become proficient in using a fretless, you'll have another great and expressive tool to pull out of your toolbox when playing with different artists.
 
I am expecting my eldest to cover at least 2/3 with grants and scholarships, and hopefully more than that.
We only had one, and when he graduated from college and became a self-supporting adult, it was the biggest raise I ever got. And then spent on our house and a newer car for my wife and... Oh, well.