Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Why do i have to solder when changing pickups?
- Thread starter odin70
- Start date
Well they do have quick-connect pickups that you just plug in, but the pickup still needs to be solidly attached to the bass if for nothing else that the capability of height adjustment and screws are the easiest and cheapest way to do that.
emg makes a total plug and play system, all except the output jack I believe. the pickups and tone controles all have simple plug in conections.
the problem is I think frequent use of these plugs would cause excessive wear and result in loose plugs, combine this with all the vibration involved and you get bad conections and noise.
the problem is I think frequent use of these plugs would cause excessive wear and result in loose plugs, combine this with all the vibration involved and you get bad conections and noise.
I agree. I'm a horrible solder-er if you could even call what I do soldering. It's more like me sitting there with a hot poker on a soldering joint staring at it waiting for something to happen for 10 minutes. (it usually never does so 10 minutes is about my give-up and quit time limit) There has to be a better/faster way to change things out. Some basses and guitars do have wiring harnesses with the connecting clips already attached so there's one semi-solution. I'm sure there's a wire here or there you'd still have to end up soldering somewhere. As far as the screws that's just plain laziness if you don't want to have to deal with those.
The point of the screws and the soldering is that its cheap and reliable.
Usually the least reliable electrical parts of a bass are the jack, the potentiometers and switches. That's because those are places where the electrical signal relies on a push contact, which is a terrible way to connect two circuits.
It could definitely be done with magnets/lego type connectors but you would be adding expense to make the instrument more likely to suddenly fail for a feature most people would never use.
Usually the least reliable electrical parts of a bass are the jack, the potentiometers and switches. That's because those are places where the electrical signal relies on a push contact, which is a terrible way to connect two circuits.
It could definitely be done with magnets/lego type connectors but you would be adding expense to make the instrument more likely to suddenly fail for a feature most people would never use.
Points are probably that the vast majority of buyers never change the pickups, and it's the cheapest and most secure way to connect them.
don't know if the magnets are a good idea, the tone of the bass has a great deal to do with the magnetic field created by the pickups add more magnets and you change the field=change the tone(and if you don't believe this then why change pickups?)
I like the lego pickups though maybe emg and fisher price can get togeather on that
I like the lego pickups though maybe emg and fisher price can get togeather on that
by the way guys soldering is a real handy skill to have and it's not that hard but their are a few tricks that you need to learn to master it get someone who knows what their doing to WATCH YOU do it then tell you what your doing wrong, once you get it figured out it's super easy
If you want to swap out various components easily, try these:
[Invalid or Expired Link Removed]
Each wire entry port can accept multiple small gage wires. They also come in versions with numerous openings.
They take up a lot more space, but they make it easy to make very good connections that are very easy to do, and un-do.
WAGO: The Lego of wiring!
Changing the pickups for studio, live etc. sounds highly impractical and totally not worth the time. Just get a bunch of basses and equip them with suitable pickups. Besides, it's way cooler to own five basses than one bass and five sets of pickups.
For the record. I know how to solder. But often if when im working in the studio i think that it would be nice to try "another" pickup. In my opinion it should be like this: loosen the strings, take of the pup, put on another one...click. I could go from a vintage pup to e.g a QP in one minute.
Better in that case with a system where you can change the pickups from the back of the bass. Just drop in through the body.
If you want the ease of doing that start a company. The price would considerably higher and you still need a way to adjust the height.
It's like saying why put lug nuts on wheels?
It's like saying why put lug nuts on wheels?
Im not able to do it, but there are a LOT of people who can. It would be way cheaper (and easier to carry) than having 5 basses. The only reason why i have different basses is because of the different pickups (more or less). One click and you could go from a jazz to a music man..if think thats a good idea and i bet the right folks would make a lot of money if they made and sold a system like that.
