• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Why Jimi Hendrix is so Important

And yet, most people have no idea who they are. They didn't write any songs that are iconic in rock history.

And that is a problem for their legacy, now isn't it
?

IMO songwriting has nothing to do with the Man's longevity/staying power other than as a vehicle for his guitar playing.

Of course being Jimi Hendrix in the JHExp got his name out there, and the new material was a good product, BUT the guitar is why he was, why he still is, and why he will always (most likely) be remembered.
 
IMO songwriting has nothing to do with the Man's longevity/staying power other than as a vehicle for his guitar playing.

Of course being Jimi Hendrix in the JHExp got his name out there, and the new material was a good product, BUT the guitar is why he was, why he still is, and why he will always (most likely) be remembered.

That is one argument I don't have a problem with.
 
I made it to the end and was frankly underwhelmed. Nothing there to make me go wow? If he was unknown and you put it on youtube - would it go viral? I doubt it very much.

The same could be said about almost any music recorded more than 6 years ago. At least from what I've seen, viral songs on YouTube are either novelty tracks or crazily over produced pop nonsense mostly aimed at children or teens.

Hendrix is definitely not The Bed Intruder or Friday by Rebecca Black...
 
When "Axis: Bold As Love" came out, the coolest black guy in my high school said to me, "You do realize that Jimi Hendrix is the Second Coming, don't you?" He was dead serious.

I mumbled something noncommittal, and he said, pityingly, "I really thought you were smart enough to see the truth." (The same guy also explained to me when Vanilla Fudge's first single was on the radio that he knew that the band must be black. "Listen to those drums, man!")

Hendrix was a competent, journeyman R&B player when he was backing Curtis Knight, etc.---but he didn't have anything like a truly original style in his early career. Eric Clapton more or less invented the role of the virtuoso lead guitarist by stealing every lick he could from John Mayall's gigantic collection of blues records and using what he'd learned to create the first unmistakably original rock style.

Hendrix undoubtedly could have done the same thing, but he never took the monk-like approach Clapton did to studying all the master bluesmen---anyway, he was too busy working.

If there's one aspect of Hendrix's career that qualifies him as the greatest rock something, if not the greatest rock guitarist, it's that he was the first---and still the only---black American musician to turn the tables on all of the British rock bands who had ripped off American blues musicians when he ripped off Cream, the Yardbirds, etc., beating them at their own game. Ginger Baker, that bitter old man, is still furious about Chas Chandler waiting for Cream to go off on a U.S. tour and then booking Hendrix as a substitute into all of the venues in the UK and Europe where Cream had been playing (he says, "Jimi was nothing like as good as Eric, Noel was no Jack, and Mitch wasn't as good as me!").
 
I was the proverbial kid when the first Hendrix LP came out- I was partly fascinated, and partly freaked. Took me several years to really get my ears around it all. By which time, he was gone...

After all these years, I'd have to say I'm in complete agreement with mr. mellowinman! I'd only stress that, for my money, Jimi is still
absurdly under-rated as a songwriter. Normally, I don't favor concepts like "greatest guitar player," since there's room for any number of greats in any genre, yes? But if anyone merits the title "greatest rock guitarist," well, who else could it be? The reason it has to be
Jimi is simply that he was, far and away, more original and more unique than any other player yet heard.

When you're young, it's easy to get caught up in "who's the fastest" and other such stuff. Once you've acquired some serious mileage on your soul (not to mention potholes and skidmarks), you find that certain artists only grow in meaning and depth- and for me, Jimi is one of those, no question.

Sing on, brother! Play on, drummer!
 
I made it to the end and was frankly underwhelmed. Nothing there to make me go wow? If he was unknown and you put it on youtube - would it go viral? I doubt it very much.

It went viral, 60's style, back when interest was measured in dollars, not mouse clicks. Album was #3 in the US, 5 in UK. The song has been covered by countless artist including Clapton, Santana, Stevie Ray, Sting and John Mayer. One Hendrix version on youtube posted 8 months ago has 700k+ hits. A Vaughn version has 1.5 million. There are thousands of Little Wing postings on youtube. Not bad for 50 year old song. Apparently others hear something you don't.

I put Hendrix in a completely different category than other guitarists because he didn't really play the guitar. The guitar was an extension of his body, soul and spirit. It was part of him and it expressed what was inside of him.

Played left handed, upside down, strung up backwards in outrageous outfits with superb showmanship, the embodiment of cool rock guitar.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pacojas
Ginger Baker, that bitter old man, is still furious about Chas Chandler waiting for Cream to go off on a U.S. tour and then booking Hendrix as a substitute into all of the venues in the UK and Europe where Cream had been playing (he says, "Jimi was nothing like as good as Eric, Noel was no Jack, and Mitch wasn't as good as me!").

"...but Eric was a guitar player, Jimi was some sort of force of nature." Jack Bruce in the following link.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Spectrum
I've always had a hard time digesting anyone who vehemently slams Hendrix as a hack. In fact, I find it hard to even talk to someone after they tell me they can't get into his work. It's just the way it is. I'm perfectly happy not dealing with the anti-Hendrix crowd. I still remember the first time I met someone (a guitarist...) who claimed that Hendrix was no more than a noodlewank. I was stunned. It might speak to my personality in a negative way to voice these feelings, but I think it speaks more to the insecurities of others who just can't wrap their heads around the concept of SOUL.
 
I've always had a hard time digesting anyone who vehemently slams Hendrix as a hack. In fact, I find it hard to even talk to someone after they tell me they can't get into his work. It's just the way it is. I'm perfectly happy not dealing with the anti-Hendrix crowd. I still remember the first time I met someone (a guitarist...) who claimed that Hendrix was no more than a noodlewank. I was stunned. It might speak to my personality in a negative way to voice these feelings, but I think it speaks more to the insecurities of others who just can't wrap their heads around the concept of SOUL.

Funny isn't it? There are few artists I feel as passionately about as Jimi.
 
Ok, this is not even debatable, Steve Ray Vaughn got the fattest Strat tone in history, and it's not even close :)

Right, he got that tone while trying to copy Hendrix.

IMO it's silly to bring up SRV in any discussion where one is bad mouthing Hendrix, considering the shockingly obvious and profound influence the latter had on the former.
 
Right, he got that tone while trying to copy Hendrix.

IMO it's silly to bring up SRV in any discussion where one is bad mouthing Hendrix, considering the shockingly obvious and profound influence the latter had on the former.

I'm not "bad mouthing" Hendrix, I actually really like him. Steve did get a fatter tone, though, in part because of his 13 gauge strings; btw, Jimi was not his only influence. Richie Blackmore and Gary Moore also got fatter Strat tones -- so what?
 
This fatter than Jimi's Strat tone stuff is probably because they used stuff that wasn't around when Jimi was, like Ibanez Tube Screamers and other pedals.

The foundation of Jimi's live effects was a Dallas Arbiter Fuzz Face and a Vox wah-wah. Often that was it, especially early on.

Jimi would drive the gear dude nuts about the the sound of the Fuzz Face(es). He'd like one, then not like it or like another one. They finally figured out what the deal was. It was the battery strength. A new fully charged 9v battery didn't sound as good a worn one with less power. I believe they made notes of the acceptable power range so they'd have some and Jimi would like the sound.

He just about always used a Gibson with HB's on Red House. I read that the Red House on the Polydor RU Exp album was a Hofner, but it sounds like a Strat to me. It's also on the Blues CD.
 
Everyone has a right to their opinion about Hendrix, of course, but personally I only value opinions of those who were around and listening to rock music in the period just before and during his rise to prominence.

I might have a strong opinion about the influence of Duke Ellington on jazz, for example, but it's not worth much because I have zero personal experience of the musical and cultural environment in which he arose.

This is why it is pointless to compare Hendrix to anyone who came after him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tbz