• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Will bassists soon no longer be needed?

I can't count the number of times I've seen the people at my school give a disgusted face every time they see me lugging my bass, or the numerous times I've heard people say, "your "instrument" just goes "don don don" loudly, its not even musical or nice sounding, what's the point of you playing it?"
It sounds as if they've listened to an incredibly narrow selection of (very probably) third rate music that will be all but forgotten in five years time, and then decided that a sketchy basis like that is enough for them to hold meaningful opinions. Ah, the folly of youth. We've all been there.

I wonder if your friends could get a groove like this going on a guitar synth or a keyboard?

 
I think you'll find that the demand for bassist is still strong. And will be. If you're still in school make it point to put time in on an UR.

And don't listen to negative people. One of the keys to a happy life is surround yourself with positive people.
 
It sounds as if they've listened to an incredibly narrow selection of (very probably) third rate music that will be all but forgotten in five years time, and then decided that a sketchy basis like that is enough for them to hold meaningful opinions. Ah ,the folly of youth. We've all been there.

I wonder if your friends could get a groove like this going on a guitar synth or a keyboard?



I've seen many people wearing Disco Sucks t shirts.

The fact is some of it is pretty darn good and the bass was always an important part of the music.

Except the Bee Gees
 
To a point the OP is right. . . If you're a fan of hardcore metal like djent, you may know some of those bands are almost as far down as a bassist. An example would be Tosin Abasi, he plays an 8 string guitar, and his lowest string is a bass E string. His band, Animals As Leaders, doesn't have nor need a bassist.
 
No.

The only band that can get away with not having a bassist is the White Stripes...and even Jack used an octave pedal on "Seven Nation Army" to at least emulate a bass.

Maybe this is just bias, but the first thing I notice in a song is the bass line. If that were to somehow disappear the song would lose a certain "something."

IMO, the reason bands at your high school don't have bassists is because a lot of kids think that playing bass is "less cool" than guitar. It's the same thing at my high school: billions of "guitarists" only three bassists (including myself)...and there's only two drummers (full kit drummers, not marching band percussionists).

Anyway, stick with the low end. You'll be in demand eventually.
 
Touring bands starting out are having a smaller footprint than in the past due to basic economics...
when the tour vehicle is a prius and not an 18 passenger van because the gas is simply unaffordable, the svt and bassist along with backup singers and extra guitar get left at home (usually replaced by backing tracks unfortunately).
All the fat has to get cut to function.
Unless, of course, the core member/ writer happens to play bass.
I personally think it's nice to see the standard format being broken up, it allows the instrument to make that much more of an impact and statement when used.
 
Thanks for all the advice and replies guys. Really helped to ease my mind. The good news was I managed to come up 2nd in a talent show my school had for a solo bass performance out of like 40 contestants.(I lost to a ballet dancer). Nothing much to brag about, but at least its now clear to me that bass won't be going anywhere soon. Oh, as for the people who commenting my bass just went "don don don" I think I've shut them up for now considering I went "thwackity boom pop" more in the show.

On the upside as well, I'm also starting to take music and double bass lessons as well. :D
 
IMO, bassists need to start thinking more in terms of "Bass - the musical function", and less in terms of "Bass - the musical instrument". Whenever there has been music, nearly right from the beginning, there has been bass - whether it be the figured bass of classical orchestral music during the Baroque period, or the tuba of a John Phillips Sousa march - or the synth bass of a Gary Numan tech/pop piece. Bass is a fundamental element of music - and likely will always be so.
MM

Indeed. Nothing wrong with playing bass on a non-stringed instrument. In fact it might cause you rethink the way play bass on the stringed one, and how it serves the composition.

And now for a brief trip back to the 80's:
 
The role of bass function in music just over the past 100+ years should be common knowledge to every bassist here, regardless of which instrument we choose to play.

The upright bass (aka string bass, double bass, contrabass, etc) has been around in varying forms dating back to the 15th century. It's changed in terms of design and materials, but is relatively unchanged since the 19th century. It's the lowest pitched of the viol family, and serves that bass function with both arco and pizzicato technique in orchestras. And it's been widely used in jazz and other popular music forms through the 20th century.

On the brass end of things, the tuba has also been serving a bass function in music. It's been used in a variety of ensembles including orchestras, and traditional New Orleans brass bands. In fact, it's common for some bassists in the New Orleans tradition to double on tuba as well as upright bass. Why? Because it's impractical to march while playing an upright bass. The tuba & it's cousin, the sousaphone, are much better suited to marching ensembles that are a big part of the New Orleans style.

The electric bass is still a very new instrument in the world of bass instruments. And it can play parts that are in the pitch range of it's predecessors, the tuba and the upright bass. Electric bass continues to evolve in terms of it's design, which is a natural part of the process.

And we've also seen developments on the keyboard front in terms of those instruments filling the bass role. Organs were the earliest keyboard instruments that were able to fill that role, but were impractical to transport. Organ-like pedals have been used for synth purposes, with players like John Paul Jones and Geddy Lee using them to play bass parts with their feet while they played more traditional keyboard parts with their hands. And keyboard technology has evolved, with synth bass being generated by early keyboards like the Moog. Those sounds seem to have found a niche in pop & dance music.

Now, I've seen an increase in bass players in pop music who double on electric bass and keyboard bass. That seems to be in increasing demand. But still, those musicians are fulfilling a BASS ROLE in the ensemble. It's just a different instrument that's being used to play those parts, and it's the nature of the instrument that's offering a different timbre/texture that some artists want for their bass parts.
 
Well, you know, now that we have the electric bass, there's just no point in having an upright. You'd never see anyone use one of those these days. Madness I tell you! So this is most certainly going to be the death of the bass for all. We should just all pack up and leave. The world doesn't want us anymore. Sorry guys.
 

Latest posts