So I was referred to here from the Praise and Worship thread, and I'm sure you have already covered it, but what pedals are absolutely needed if you were building a pedal board from scratch.
This is what I'm thinking so far, please offer any advice and criticism.
Tuner, Turbo Tuner ST-300
Grit/distortion, Dark Glass B3K
Into my Fender rumble head which has onboard compression, distortion, and a DI. It's class D and small enough to fit on a larger pedal board. Add the channel switch for the rumble distortion, so I can have two distortions set up differently and foot switchable.
Thoughts?
Currently my church uses a Boss tuner into a Sansamp, and that's it. No extra grit, no anything, although I know they can add compression and reverb to the signal at the sound board.
This discussion has galloped off into favourite pedal territory as this sort of forum discussion always does. My first thought is, there is no "absolutely needed". There is only "want" and "suitable to do what I want to do". So let's take one step back, surely the question is... what do you want to do? And what sounds do you want to create? When? On what songs?
All that is NEEDED is a cable and a simple DI box... but that's dull. So what are your desires and applications? For 20 or so years I never used effects. When I started playing I tried out compressors and limiters, flange and chorus. But after 5 or so years I ditched them all for just an amp (and bog standard DI when needed). I picked up a Wah about 15 years ago for three specific songs we did in the covers band I played in and it was only about 4ish years ago I started experimenting with effects in worship. Here's the board I've ended up with and my personal reasoning/requirements...
So why these... In order of need priority...
Tuner - 100% "need". Like the Boss TU-2/3 but love the PolyTune.
Sansamp VTDI - very strong preference, almost need. Our previous WL had a desire to go amp free and ultimately IEM so I got this as a preamp/amp & speaker sim. I'd used various borrowed Sansamp before so went straight for this one. I run it pretty much clean in Ampeg B15 mode, which suits my preference. I've never been one for heavily overdriven basses. People complain about it having a "baked in" tone but since that is Ampeg B15 and SVT (+silly distortion mode I'll never use)... I don't see the problem. From here on in its all discretionary for me.
Chorus & Tremolo - my 25 year old CE-2B resurrected and EHX tremolo. These are for subtle dynamic effects to give some different flavour to sections of certain songs. For example, chorus on a slow ballad or trem on a downbeat bridge with long sustained notes. Also good for ambient noodling behind a speaker with the treble/attack rolled off.
Wah - I like the Morley because of its two modes, conventional Wah and funk mode which is more akin to an envelope filter. Back in the early 2000s when the band were playing those 3 songs I could never find an auto Wah out envelope filter pedal which reacted dynamically in the way I wanted/liked so manual (?podular?) seemed the way to go. I love the sound of this pedal in small doses. In worship I use it to give a synthy sound for EDM style basslines (Let Praise Awaken, Alive etc). Which is where the
Overdrive comes in. I don't have a need for distortion and would never use an always on OD. I deliberately bought the Bass Soul Food because it is such a low gain pedal and because it has a blend control. It just adds a touch of square/sawtooth into the Wah to enhance the synth type effect. I do rarely bung it on to liven up a rocky number (You Are Good, Shout For Joy) but not much...
So that's why my board looks like this... no compressor, no octave, no distortion, no phaser, no whatever... because they aren't tones/effects I want or need. What are your specs? Best to ask that question before you start buying stuff!
And yes, most online demos are really frustrating "everything up to 11" affairs.