Just a question – do any of you folks feel that the bass comes in 1) too early and 2) too low in modern worship songs?
I've lost track of how many Hillsongs where the bass just thunders in low whilst all the other instruments are still playing dynamically light and high.
Maybe it's a style thing. I tend to save my low notes for the bigger dynamic moments and play up the neck until later in the song. My gigging background has a lost of Post-Rock/Post-Metal so I like to keep the power of the bass ready for huge moments but noticed that if I play along note-for-note with most worship songs, they let the cat out of the bag pretty much straight away.
I'm questioning my approach a little – is there something I'm not giving the congregation by saving those notes still what I think is a more dynamically appropriate time?
I think it's totally a stylistic choice, and also simplistic by design.
That being said, I totally feel you. I find myself wamting to diddle around with the high registers early on...then go low to build. Sounds like a Great plan, but that wasn't how it was written. I'm just tired of the same boring, droning bass. It's like it's written to just be carried by the keyboard, but they just feltlike having bass just to have another person. End jaded rant.