Okay, so I'll come back to last night's gig.
This is a good pickup. What initially drew me to it was the way it is mounted on the bass and the claims of quality of construction and I'm not disappointed. It is a precision machined component that feels like it enhances my setup rather than something flimsy or awkward attached to it. The only issue I have in this regard is that my bridge needed some material removed to accommodate the added thickness. I'd also like a clean way to attach and remove the jack when I wasn't using it. For now, I have it mounted to the tailpiece and it's not a big deal to take it off, but it involves enough effort that I'm just leaving it on there. I may play with velcro at some point, but it's not bothering me.
Sonically it is hot, but I don't think that's a problem for now. I'm able to control it. Someone did post a video clip of my gig last night and I noticed that I was very tender with my right hand, so I wonder if I was holding back, but practicing today I don't see a reason that it shouldn't be manageable as is.
It is very hifi, much moreso than any other pickup I've used except the Stat-B. With the 4 band parametric eq on my iAmp, I can dial in the tone I want and have it sound like whatever I want it to. This is something I've never been good at and I'm mostly convinced that it's because the pickups I've been using were already voiced and frequencies that I'm adjusting now maybe just weren't there before. I've not been using my micro head which has a basic 3-band low-mid-high eq and it's possible that I won't with this pickup. The more powerful eq, at least for now seems to be important. As is a hpf, which is something else that I've never thought was as important as everyone says, but I used off and on, usually with bad stages, but I would not go out without it with the Yamahiko right now. I think that it's also impedance buffering, which might be part of it. I've experimented with my SansAmp paradriver at home and I like some things about it, but it doesn't replace the hpf and I can't get my brain around eq on a pedal and another eq on the amp. Seems overkill or at least complicated. I do wonder if there is an ideal pre-amp for this pickup that will a) buffer impedence b) give you hpf and c) help you control those frequencies.
At home, in addition to the hpf, I drop the bass -5 at about 60 hz, and cut low-mid a little bit to manage the bloom and hi-mid to reduce the string noise. I can make it dark like a Realist, but don't, just sweep and dial in the sound I want. On the last two gigs, I've ended up putting those frequencies back in to get to a similar sound. I don't think I'm quite dialed in on this yet, but I like what I'm hearing and knowing that I have that control. I just need to get better at it.
I've tried going into the active input on my amp, but it didn't seem to make things better in any way.
But, it's not magic. On the gig last night, there wasn't a great place for amp. We were kind of pushed into a corner and it generally sounded too dark or too diffuse to me, but I don't think it would have been different with another pickup, I just couldn't get myself in a position where I was hearing the amp the way that the room was.
The thing that kept me from moving on this pickup before now was the cost, but it was about $30 more than a Realist Lifeline or Full Circle based on the exchange rate, so my timing was good in that regard.
I don't see questioning my purchase or going away from it. I do think it's going to require a little more attention than the types of pickups I have preferred, but I might be ready for that. What's bothering me right now is too much change. I added the RobPin and reshaped the bridge when I was creating accommodation for this pickup and it's a lot to adjust to at once. I think all of it will be better than the alternatives once I'm through it, though.