• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass Yet another tuner post

Many (almost all) of the electronic tuners I've used have a hard time sensing the low E on a bass. I made this observation in a music store a few years back, and the clerk sold me a tuner made exclusively for bass. It only sensed 4 notes, but I rarely had problems with it hearing the E string. I think it was made by Korg, but am not 100% sure. It also was very affordable.

Well, I think I may have finally lost my bass tuner for the last time, and haven't been able to find anything similar online. Apparently this excellent bass tuner isn't made anymore? The store where I bought the original is far away, so I'm not going there soon.

Who can point me to a tuner that can consistently hear the low E?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: gerry grable
I like the Petersen Strobo Clip the best. I have one for each bass. Not cheap, and takes a little getting used to, due to the strobe readout, but always hears the E and the E tuned down to D which I do very seldom. There was a recent thread on this subject - did you search?
 
I own the Meisel 90, and having read the other thread bought a Polyclip from TC Electronics. This is the best tuner I've ever used for speed and compactness. Worth the $50 and the extra $ over the Meisel.

The 3 minute auto shutoff is worth it alone. Not so great if you use it to check intonation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scottkarch
Thanks guys. I agree that I should call the experts and take their advice. I should have thought of that first, but at least I did think to ask the experts.

I know are a lot of other threads about tuners, but I didn't see my specific question addressed well, which is hearing the low E. In afterthought, I could have named the thread better; or understood that if a DB player recommends a particular tuner, it's because it hears the low E well.

The way I misplace things, I'm not sure I can go the premium route But I'm sure Mr. G. will have just the thing for me.

Thanks again!
 
It seems that frequently, when OP's resolve their issue, there is no feedback or closure. So, FWIW, I received my Meisel 90 from Golihur's a couple of weeks ago, and it'll probably do just fine; but...

When I 1st clipped it on my bass, all strings were dead on in tune (Spriocore mittells after 2 weeks), but 1/2 step high…hmmm. Same thing when I tuned my jazz band's practice bass the next day. Except that after i re-tuned, I checked again and all strings still were 1/2 step high. What the…….????!!! So I re-tuned and checked again and tuning now read a full step low. So I tuned back up, and tuning matched the piano; so I left well enough alone, and stuck the tuner in the bag for the night.

The next day at home, I thought I should see if there was some sort of manual or something for the tuner, before complaining to the vendor. Whoever heard of having to look at a manual to use a tuner? If a manual was included with the tuner, it must have been folded very small and hidden, and I threw it away. But I soon found a PDF manual on Golihur's website (all hail!), and quickly discovered that for some strange reason it is very easy to program the tuner so that it reads either 1/2 or 1 step flat. Apparently this for people who can't play guitar and have to use capos, and are too lazy to remove the capo to tune the guitar, and are too stupid to calculate half steps in their head. Whoda thunk???? I really don't get it. It seems the capo would impede string movement, and tuning would not be accurate.

Other than that, the tuner is very precise (almost too precise). It hears the low E just fine (my original question), but sometimes gets confused on the A string and calls it E, but not so bad that I can't tell what's going on. The balance of the tuner could be better; I'm used to clipping the tuner on my music stand when not in use, but this one is a bit awkward on the music stand.

So, in general, I think I like the tuner OK, but not as much as the $12 Korg bass tuner that I lost (only hears 4 notes and hears them well), and apparently they don't make any more. I'm a bit frustrated with how it's over-engineered to do too many things that nobody needs anyway. I tend to blame it all on Bill Gates, who became way too rich by over engineering Microsoft programs, but I'm sure others contributed to this modern trend as well.

I'll stop now before entering full rant mode. I guess I'm just an old malcontent who's reached the age where I hate change. (I blame Bill Gates on the modern trend of 'planned obsolescence' too…)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Jsn
TC Poly Tune Clip tuner. Simple, accurate, and way ahead of almost everything else out there. A number of onlines sell it for about $49. Probably the last clip on you'll buy until they come out with something substantially better. Somewhat similar to the TC Electronics stompbox tuner, in clip form.
 
I recently picked up a Korg Pitchhawk G2 clip-on and it reads the low 'E' on DB like a boss. (But it's not a Boss, it's a Korg!)
Around $15US.
Lucky you, I paid more than twice as much here in Europe.

It also read the low B well if clipped to the bridge.
Clipped to the pegbox the low E reads very well, the low B not as well but probably acceptable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bassfran
I still use the old Boss TU-12 I've had since the 80s. I like the real needle dial instead of LEDs, although I have a strobe tuner (a Turbo Tuner) on the floor too.

tu12_main.jpg
 
or some strange reason it is very easy to program the tuner so that it reads either 1/2 or 1 step flat. Apparently this for people who can't play guitar and have to use capos, and are too lazy to remove the capo to tune the guitar, and are too stupid to calculate half steps in their head. Whoda thunk???? I really don't get it. It seems the capo would impede string movement, and tuning would not be accurate.
You are being a bit mean here, although mostly accurate. Since you are using an electronic tuner, you are hardly in a position to rant on technology. Don't forget that Baroque players generally tune down a semitone. This feature might be for them, not guitarists.
As to Bill Gates; at least with Windows you can go in and tweak your settings. With Apple devices I am unable to play MP3s that haven't been created in a way which conforms to the Itunes ID3 tag system, and no easy way to view the files on your device directly. Really stupid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Who da Ville