I've been hired to write a response to the travesty of an article on jazz.com reviling bass solos. So I'm soliciting your opinions on favorite tracks from historically significant bassists. A few on my list are: Jimmy Blanton, Oscar Pettiford, Ray Brown, Red Mitchell... You get the idea. Thanks in advance for your input.
I love all of Jim Kerwin's solo's on the Jerry Garcia/David Grisman album "So What" Ray Brown's solo(s) on Bag's groove from the album "Super Bass"
Congrats on the gig, I guess. From my perspective it's all bits and bites. I don't care if somebody on jazz.com does or doesn't like bass solos. I like some and dislike others. Who cares?
I agree with Sam. To me, music is music. Who cares if it's played on a bass, or a sax or a trumpet? The instrument isn't as important as the musical personality. That said, just about anything Scott LaFaro ever played is on my favorites list. Check out My Man's Gone Now from Sunday at the Vanguard.
For that matter any of the Bill Evans Trio Village Vanguard recordings, Scott Lafaro has the most melodic interesting solos(even to horn players) so it would be the perfect counterpoint to that aforementioned article.
I'll go one step further. I think that guy was looking to ruffle some feathers and get a response. Responding might just be validating him. A gigs a gig though. Maybe you can respond by not citing examples but rather pointing out the silliness of his argument.
The piece I'm doing is only obliquely a response to Mr. Kurtz. Really it is a contribution to their Dozens series in which a writer chooses 12 tracks to review that are somehow thematically linked. I did an earlier piece on Dave Holland's music for them. That said, if anyone else would like to make actual suggestion of favorite tracks to review that would be most welcome. Thanks.
Red Mitchell's solo on THESE FOOLISH THINGS off ALL NIGHT SESSIONS ditto on YOU"D BE SO NICE OP on STARDUST (technically cello, but ...) Sam Jones HOW ABOUT YOU off JIMMY RANEY LIVE IN TOKYO George Mraz pretty much anything Michael Moore I SHOULD CARE of LIVE AT MAYBECK w/ Bill Charlap Peter Washington BEST THING FOR YOU WOULD BE ME off Billy Drummond's DUBAI
I actually have 4 recordings of OP playing Stardust, but they're all on bass. I'd be interested in hearing a cello version. All 4 versions I have are great. I find the similarities very interesting. Pettiford seemed to have a kind of arrangement of this piece in his head as he uses many of the same ideas in the same places in all 4 recordings.
My teacher, Joe, played me a recording of an aircheck at (original) Birdland that was OP on cello, the two tracks I heard were PERDIDO and STARDUST. But yeah, the solo that most folks play is off that first record....
I don't know if the cello thang is available commercially, I'll try to run down where Joe got and cop, if possible....
I just thought of another, there's and album called Looking at Bird by Archie Shepp and Niels Henning Orsted Pederson doing Duo versions of parker tunes. NHOP's playing is incredible on this one, its the only recording of him that I've heard were he had truly great tone, but all his solos are well thought out and he stays away from the ridiculously fast stuff that he sometimes does. Those to me are great solos.
I think it's great that you are doing the article. Here is a quick list (many of which are not necessarily solos) that I was compiling for a project of my own, trying to list the top 20 most important bassists in traditional jazz and their single most representative or important recordings: Walter Page Lady Be Good Count Basie: America's #1 Band Count Basie Milt Hinton Pluckin the Bass How Low Can You Go? Anthology of the String Bass Various Jimmie Blanton Jack the Bear The Blanton-Webster Band Duke Ellington Leroy Slam Stewart I Got Rhythm The Smithsonian Collection of Classic Jazz Various Israel Crosby But Not For Me Cross Country Tour 1958-1961 Ahmad Jamal Trio Oscar Pettiford Tricotism Tricotism Lucky Thompson Charles Mingus - II.BS Wilbur Ware Softly, As in a Morning Sunrise Live at the Village Vanguard, Vol. 2 Sonny Rollins Ray Brown How High the Moon The Oscar Peterson Trio Live at the Stratford Shakespearean Festival - Oscar Peterson Percy Heath Walkin Miles Davis All Stars Walkin Miles Davis Sam Jones - having trouble thinking of the most representative performance by him Jimmy Garrison Acknowledgement A Love Supreme John Coltrane Paul Chambers So What Kind of Blue Miles Davis (of course there are millions of solos - If I Were a Bell, Visiation, on and on - I chose So What because I was trying to get to ONE song choice and ultimately I think this is symbolic for him Charlie Haden something off of The Shape of Jazz to Come Ornette Coleman Scott LaFaro Glorias Step Sunday at the Village Vanguard Bill Evans Ron Carter My Funny Valentine The Complete Concert 1964 My Funny Valentine + Four & More Miles Davis Hope this helps in some way. May I also suggest for solos specifically: Sometimes I'm Happy - Ray Brown, OP Trio Live in Chicago Pettiford - Just You Just Me - The Unique Thelonious Monk, Falling in Love with Love, +1 for Stardust Blanton - Pitter Panther Patter and Sepia Panorama PC - All of You, Visitation, Please Send Me Someone, If I Were A Bell, Blue Train, Yesterdays, Bye-Bye Blackbird Mingus - Tensions from Blues and Roots Best Matt Rybicki
Dave Holland- Solar Either from Emerald tears or from that one with Dejohnette, Hancock, and Metheny. Or Take the Coltrane- Triplicate. Or Segment- same album. Christian McBride- Basically anything, but how about Birk's Works from Superbass II.