• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Your Four Basses Forever

Your Four Basses Forever

I have an idea for a little game that should be fun and maybe even enlightening. It’s based on one I enjoyed on a car blog, but adapted for our interests.



The main idea is: If you could have any four basses in the world for the rest of your life, cost no object, what would you choose?

Here are the rules:

1. Forever. You may only own and only play these four basses, for the rest of your life.

2. Cost no object / no monetary value. These basses (or the materials) will be bought for you. You may not sell them or give them away, and you may not buy others or have others gifted, or make others for yourself. The four will be destroyed on your death. So, they have zero monetary value. All service, including wear items and refrets, is free for life.

3. No mods. You can specify your pickups et cetera, but once you receive the instrument it stays that way forever, aside from replacing strings or worn parts. No defretting a fretted, or fretting a fretless. Yes, you may change string types and brands.

4. No prestige / historical / hero worship. For example, you can ask for a perfect replica of Jaco’s Bass of Doom, which feels, looks, and sounds precisely the same and is indistinguishable from the original, but not the actual BOD. This is about playing bass, not provenance.

5. Types of instruments. Fretted and fretless bass guitars, ERBs, ABGs, DBs, Chapman Sticks, Warr guitars, Ashborys, bass ukes, bass banjos and the like are all good. Must be a bass-range stringed instrument, or bass-range plus. Let’s leave out things like pianos and harps where you don’t pluck the string and/or you don’t stop the string against some kind of neck to change the pitch. Also, note that if you play DB, be sure to include one, or you won’t have one.

6a. Actual instruments. Specify an actual brand or builder, and the model and aspects of the instrument to be bought or built. Not just ”a bass that sounds like x and plays like y and looks like z.” And of course, you can list an instrument you already own.

6b. Your own build is OK. It doesn’t have to be a purchased instrument, if you’d like to include one or more of your own builds. The magical anonymous patron will cover your materials, and any subcontractor costs. But the same rules apply as far as no modifications after the fact, no sales, etc.


I think this will be fun!

I’m putting this on the Luthier's Corner first, and after a while I intend to post on the main Basses forum. We can see what the differences will be, which will be interesting, and may even be useful for those here who build as a business. (I know cross-posting is generally not allowed, but mods, please let me know if you think it will not be OK in this particular case.)


Now have at it! Feel free to elaborate on the details, that makes it all the more interesting.
 
2016 Rickenbacker 4003 - Classic sound and looks. In mapleglo, of course. If they were all in a room, and I was picking one out, and they had a snowglo, I may walk out with that one, but I don't think they're making that color this year. I'm building a 5 string Rickenfacker - if it comes out well, I'll take that one.
2016 American Fender Precision - Everyone needs one.
2016 American Fender Precision 5 string - Gotta have a 5 string, so why not another Precision. The 5 string Rics were a disaster. I'll take the one I built on this one.
5 String Ritter Roya - Cost no object. I've never played one, nor seen one in the flesh, but Ritter basses are so elegant. I might go with an R-8 or R-8 concept. The only single cut body style I like.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MattZilla
Red Warwick Corvette $$:
EjBQsFW.jpg

The perfect metal bass.


This Mayones:
OqId9ei.jpg

The most beautiful finish on a wenge bass I've seen, and to me, one of the most proportionally concise instrument designs.



A Rob Allen MB-2 Koa
u31Ukoy.jpg

Rob Allen basses are what made me want to get into this. The sound is unlike any other, and the simple elegance of he design is, in my opinion, of the very finest.


and the Carl Thompson 10 million dollar bass
GUNDg5Y.jpg

Carl.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MattZilla
Since you opened this up to custom builds here is what I would do. The specs for each instrument would be the same in regards to the following:

1. Headless instruments utilizing my own "MRC Brand" head less tuning system.
2. A combination of a custom designed under saddle bridge piezo system and low-z magnetic pickups made from neodymium magnets (depends on the build - see below for the list of instruments)
3. A swappable fingerboard system to allow for multiple options - everything from fretless to custom designed fretted boards that accommodate multiple temperaments and tunings (e.g. 24EDO, 17EDO, etc.)
4. Custom designed MRC electronics, with professionally printed circuit boards.

The list:

1. A heavily chambered four string with an under saddle Fishman piezo system, and the MRC Weald wood signal processor built in. It would be strung with custom made silk strings. The body style would be my own "Chimera" body shape, which was used in this build. Featured wood would be a black limba body core and neck with a pau ferro top.

2. A 6 string bass with strings and tuning similar to the "Pawn Shop Bass VI" using both magnetic MRC low-z pickups and a Fishman under saddle piezo system. The body style would be the "Phaethon" body style, which can be seen in this build. Featured wood would be a black limba body core and neck with a macassar ebony top.

3. A 5 string bass using both magnetic MRC low-z pickups and a Fishman under saddle piezo system. The body style would be the "Aleph" body style, which can be seen in this build. Featured wood would be a black limba body core and neck with a pale moon ebony top.
 
My needs are not great.

My 1st 2 choices would be these 2 culprits. It took me a bit to find the tonal sweet spot on the 5 banger, but now that I know where it is, it's a keeper.
As for #3 and 4, I haven't built them yet.

So my approach here my be a bit different because I would not target a specific set of requirements, rather, I will just keep building instruments, and when one comes up that is in the exceptional category, I keep it!

Cheers

Misc16.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: reverendrally
F-Bass BN-5
Fender 4 string Jazz w/ Nordstrand NJ4SV's
MPG Level 5 w/ MM Pickup
Status Streamline 5
I already have the first 3 so I am good but a Streamline would a great bass to balance the ash and alder of the others.
 
A very tough call.
Spector NS-2 in Bahama Blue with a birds-eye fretboard and chrome hardware.
Pedulla Thunderbass in Blue Green Burst with the Thunderguts circuit.
Pedulla Rapture J2-5 with 19mm spacing in the discontinued Candy Purple with birds-eye fretboard and Pearloid pickgard.
And I'm torn on the last one between a Buzz, P-bass, and Uke bass...
 
Any four good 4-string basses will work equally well for me. (I really just need two. One to play and one for backup.)

I'm not very fussy about bass gear. I'll get a sound I like (and can work with) out of virtually any halfway decent bass and amp.

My extremely boring prefs are: passive, two pickups, 34" scale, rosewood or ebony fingerboard, balanced neck, tunes easily and holds intonation well, medium action, accessible truss adjustment (i.e. without needing to remove the neck), weighing in the neighborhood of 9 lbs, good looks not absolutely required - but definitely a plus, and...that's really about it. Any basses that match those prefs will be fine.

If I were only allowed to keep four of what I already have - and that would be it for whatever time I have here on earth, I'd keep:
  • '74 Gibson Ripper (this is the older '73-'75 version with the thinner neck)
  • Spector Euro ReBop-5
  • Fender PBass (pretty much unavoidable if you're playing or doing recording for other people)
  • Epiphone EL Capitan ABG
 
Last edited:

Latest posts