• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

You're maybe not gonna like this...

Cool video. No one *needs* a 5K bass. That's not the point though is it:)

All of my basses combined cost less than a lot of people spend on one bass. They are all exceptional instruments, especially considering the price. Being able to work on my own instruments also helps. I don't have to spend much to get a bass that will play like something 4 times it's price.
 
Even if it was, the tape isn't big enough to cover the butterfly. Also, I'm no Fodera expert but I've never seen one with angled tuners AND the headstock shape is wrong.
I went back to the video too. I would say that this doesn't look like a genuine Fodera. The headstock, tuners, preamp knob pattern, no brass nut, even the shape on the body, I'd say he got ripped off if he paid $5K for this one.
Even a real Fodera would make for a ridiculous test, but the decision to buy a Fodera (or a lot of high end basses) isn't just made on the sound alone. It also has to do with the fit and finish, the woods used, and most of all (to me anyway) the way it feels. My Fodera has the nicest neck I have ever played (Thanks Vinny). Whether someone else chooses to spend their money on one is entirely up to them. I'm very happy with my decision.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sixgunn
Well, they all sound different. It is not like he is comparing three P basses with different price tags. I personally like the sound of the P the best which is no way $20. But, they are different sounding basses and there's no universal 'better'. Nice video!
 
Dude can probably play better than most people here, and there are still people trying to justify the $5k price tag. Keep dreaming guys, or at least start practicing. Hanging out on TB ain't gonna get you there.
I only hang out on TB to avoid working at work and instead think about bass stuff.
 
Which car they'd rather have, or if a manager could sweep a floor, is irrelevant. The point is that a cared for $700 car is all that's needed to get to work. I'd rather have the $100,000 car too. So I could sell it and buy a car for each person in my family.
This is a silly statement because we all know a $700 car will be in constant need of repair for things that cost well over $700. In some fantasy world $700 car that isn't a complete POS that never works, doesn't have trashed interior, and doesn't cost more to maintain that buying a new may be nice. But here on planet Earth, a $700 car is a liability and a $20 bass is firewood with string on it.
Let us also not fool ourselves into thinking that if a "pro" showed up to an audition with that junker he would get the gig.
Let us also stop kidding our selves with this minimalist BS. A human can survive on two meals of nothing but water and rice everyday. Buddhist monks do it for their whole lives. Does anyone here do that? I doubt it. We could probably sew together serviceable clothing that would last us for years. Do we? We could all live in tents, but we don't. People like nice things, you have to pay more for nice things, and 99% of the time nice things are better than junky things.
Finally, no one needs a bass. No one needs music and no one needs musicians. So if you want to introduce what a person "needs" into this discussion, you have already lost.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Josh Kneisel
LESS functionality.

A $20 Timex digital watch is orders of magnitude more accurate at keeping time than any mechanical watch.
The presumption that something digital keeps time better over something analog is a false one. Poorly designed is poorly designed. I have $3000 NTP clocks at work that drift terribly when they can't sync up to an outside source. The clock in my car is off by 7 minutes right now because it runs fast. I can reset it an it will be off like this again in just a few months. A precision gear\spring clock can keep time for years with less drift.
 

Latest posts