A revive to share an impression I've gotten thru' the years and is motivating certain gear changes lately. I've used 15s all my life but recently I just can't keep ignoring the fact that my 4x10+1(or 2)x15 rigs (or the 15s alone for the case) can't compete with my Peavey 15" combos (TNT150, TKO75, TKO80) in terms of anything: articulation, punch, warmness, even "wholeness". Nowadays in fact I'm selling all my bass cabs and I don't know if I'll get some some new ones, at least in the short run. Will keep my SansAmp RBI+Hartke 3500 rack head for gigs with shared cabs, but otherwise I'm gigging with a Zoom MS60B plus 1 or 2 Peavey TNT150 combos (a second one in great condition is being delivered to me as I speak).
Now, as an example, 2 TNT combos simply blow my Hartke 215XL cab out of the water in punch and loudness and even in chest-thump and plain balls and low-end authority. Altho' I have some clues I don't exactly know what makes this setup so much better and tighter, but it definitely is, at any volume (I attribute this to the cabs, obviously I swapped preamps and all parts of the chain looking for other reasons before jumping to this conclusion, and no way, the boxes sound defintely dead/sterile/slow/uncontrolled compared to the combos).
Could it be that I found my holy grial in small enclosure sort of PA range 15 "boxy" boxes? :-( I mean, not that great a bass response, yet reliable lo-mid, and greater detail into the mids than a bass specific speaker (efficient in that zone, even tho' upper range response on what I have -Scorpions and BWs- ends at 2khz). I've seen this happen with other cabs, particularly some old and small EBS 4x10s (or the Gorm 350 4x10 combo for the case -a monster BTW-). Those came with some Eminence OEM speakers that were pretty close to Gammas IIRC, and altho' the cab's lowend response ended somewhere around 70hz it still had a great articulated AND ballsy lowend feeling to me. Or could I be looking the wrong way and it has something to do with some filtering/compression/magic going on inside the Peavey combos' head sections? (I find this harder to believe, I own all early 1990s' Peavey combos, notorious for being cheap, simple to own/maintain, clean and loud, not particularly colored much less "warmed"/"tightened")
Thanks for your comments.