I knew a girl who bought a Hyundai because the sales rep said it was exactly the same as a Honda.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Bass guitar = classical guitar, right?
- Thread starter Greenman72
- Start date
The benefits of classical guitar playing helps in my approach to the electric bass as does the benefits of electric bass help my approach to classical guitar. At the muscular level mostly.
Carrots and oranges. But you can definitely borrow and steal ideas, transfer them between the instruments. I adopted some classical/flamenco guitar elements for playing a 5 string bass...
Then there this...
Then there this...
I think they are closer than many here are saying. If you want to see something that is different than a classical guitar watch this doubler. Who also sings.
Compare bass to clarinet, accordion, or marimba to see some real differences. If your experience goes beyond rock bands into other instruments, classical and bass seem very similar. You can play bass lines on classical which is how I learned before I got a bass. I can play a lot of finger style tunes on bass.
I think any musician in western music should get familiar with piano and drums just for how much it will expand you musical understanding. And if you expand your listening choices enough, bass and classical seem like siblings. Pull out a Bass VI and you have a close cousin.
The car analogy from earlier would make more sense as saying if you learn to drive a car does that carry over to driving a station wagon or pickup truck.
EDIT: I just noticed in the video above the bass and guitar both play non ferrous strings, have many similarities in their construction, and share the same notes but the guitar gets two more strings. Which becomes more like if I can play a 4 string will that carry over to a 6 string.
Compare bass to clarinet, accordion, or marimba to see some real differences. If your experience goes beyond rock bands into other instruments, classical and bass seem very similar. You can play bass lines on classical which is how I learned before I got a bass. I can play a lot of finger style tunes on bass.
I think any musician in western music should get familiar with piano and drums just for how much it will expand you musical understanding. And if you expand your listening choices enough, bass and classical seem like siblings. Pull out a Bass VI and you have a close cousin.
The car analogy from earlier would make more sense as saying if you learn to drive a car does that carry over to driving a station wagon or pickup truck.
EDIT: I just noticed in the video above the bass and guitar both play non ferrous strings, have many similarities in their construction, and share the same notes but the guitar gets two more strings. Which becomes more like if I can play a 4 string will that carry over to a 6 string.
Last edited:
This will have to do. You can even order a six string version if that's what you want.
Last edited:
I tried a bajo quinto in a music store recently and I started playing it like a bass. The tuning was ADGCF (double courses), so I was able to play some bass lines on it because D Standard (DGCF) tuning is natural to me. That being said, the bajo quinto is much closer to a bass for me than a classical guitar.
They are clearly different, but maybe not worlds apart. IF you want to find any similarities or transferrable aspects of technique I would look more to the left hand and not the right.
Reagarding the right hand, whilst the concepts of Tirando and Apoyando apply to the electric bass the execution is not the same.
And of course synchronisation of left and right hands is crucial to both and can be practiced/developed with similar exercises.
YMMV
Last edited:
But if you can drive a cement truck can't you also drive a limo?
The cement truck stands for the bass, in case it's not obvious.
Ah, because the bass provides the foundation. And rhythm guitar is like a Toyota Yaris, right? And lead is the limousine. And the ukelele is like that annoying cyclist that cuts in front of you?
When I tried classical techniques on a bass, my playing got better.
They are distantly related; I studied classical guitar as a teen-love classical guitar music-and while it made learning bass later "easier," they are too different to properly compare. One can apply a bit of guitar technique to the bass, but most of the time, finger-style bass playing is pretty different.
In addition, I read musical notation with guitar back then, and have yet to do it with bass, for better or worse.
(Ironically, I have never properly played electric guitar, nor am interested in starting-not that it is bad to do so, of course.)
In addition, I read musical notation with guitar back then, and have yet to do it with bass, for better or worse.
(Ironically, I have never properly played electric guitar, nor am interested in starting-not that it is bad to do so, of course.)
I play both. I started classical guitar a decade and a half before starting bass, which seemed like "the same thing" at the time I considered switching. It's a computation that is easy to get wrong
I checked carrots, because you didn't leave me the correct answer.
They are not really alike, but you SHOULD take it up. Becoming a multi-instrumentalist will only help you with both instruments.
They are not really alike, but you SHOULD take it up. Becoming a multi-instrumentalist will only help you with both instruments.
Although I vote as "kind of", they are not really. But I did play classical guitar. And some techniques I did managed to incorporate into my bass playing, but all because of it's my own songwriting material. In reality, things might be a bit different.
Anyway, knowing more can't hurt.
Anyway, knowing more can't hurt.
