I think the thing to consider when it comes to overdrives is how they sound in mix. I play in a modern hard rock band. Lots of dirty
Guitars and the guitars are tuned down to B. I ended up using the darkglass Microtubes X which based on demo videos I initially would have thought was the wrong pedal for me. But it’s all about how it sounds in the mix with the band. I’ve owned many overdrive pedals over the years where the grit sounds good by itself but then when I’m playing with the band you couldn’t even tell I was using them. The microtubes x is a pretty extreme overdrive but in the mix it sounds great to me. Often times I think people who really want subtle overdrive would actually be better off using one of the nicer boost pedals on the market than an actual overdrive.