• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Black coffee appreciation

Doppio ristretto, con zucchero - I gotta have sugar in my 'stretto, please and thank you: I'm actually surprised "black" means "no milk or cream" but also "no sugar" in your parlance, but ok, noted - from the iconic stovetop Moka pot @SteveCS showed above.

It can also be called black if you put sugar in it, at least in my experience.

I'm not a Starbucks customer, tried it twice and realized it is everything I despise all rolled into one.
 
I love black coffee with no sugar. If it's horribly bitter swill I may put one sugar in it.

I generally drink iced coffee. Almost every day before work I'll order a large black ice coffee from Dunkin Donuts. Most of time I'll get what I ask for but at least once a week I'll get anything from a latte to a hot chocolate. I suppose "large black ice coffee" is hard to understand sometimes.
 
I love black coffee with no sugar. If it's horribly bitter swill I may put one sugar in it.

I generally drink iced coffee. Almost every day before work I'll order a large black ice coffee from Dunkin Donuts. Most of time I'll get what I ask for but at least once a week I'll get anything from a latte to a hot chocolate. I suppose "large black ice coffee" is hard to understand sometimes.

I drink iced espressos in the summer, the only time I'll add sugar. Just too bitter when ice cold, and I really like bitter tastes.
 
I used to have zero tolerance for people who added things to their coffee, insisting in my mind that they were ruining the experience and should be thus banned from drinking coffee.
I was convinced that once they had really good coffee, roasted and prepared properly, they would see how good it is plain and enjoy it as I do.
Well, that's not true. I tried.
I've come around in the last year or so and find that coffee is enjoyed many different ways, and it's OK if someone else doesn't enjoy it the way I do.

-Mike
 
I get an ice coffee at my local McD's every weekday.

Same as the hot coffee. Dark and bitter
It's good though. I sip on my morning ice coffee though out most of the day and supplement it with cups of hot coffee from the machine at work. Keeps the mind-numbing, soul-draining monotony of my job from driving me to insanity and burning the building to the ground.
 
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, TalkBass may receive commissions from qualifying purchases made via links on this site.
I wouldn't call it black if it had sugar. When I'm getting someone coffee, I always ask how they take it. I've heard "cream", "sugar", "cream and sugar", or "black", but never "black with sugar" -- that just sounds like an oxymoron. Black means "with nothing else added".
 
  • Like
Reactions: cfsporn
I wouldn't call it black if it had sugar. When I'm getting someone coffee, I always ask how they take it. I've heard "cream", "sugar", "cream and sugar", or "black", but never "black with sugar" -- that just sounds like an oxymoron. Black means "with nothing else added".
[;)]Uh, no it doesn't, strictly speaking, and one could argue it's still black if sugar doesn't change the colour... [/;)]
But logic has little weight in these fixed expressions. It actually appears as there's been a (relatively recent) shift in meaning.

A number of dictionaries still list milk and cream as the critical (in their absence) components and omit sugar from the definition:
black coffee - definition of black coffee in English from the Oxford dictionary
Invalid Link Removed
[This invalid link has been removed]
Link Removed
and, FWIW, Invalid Link Removed

OTOH cfr. Invalid Link Removed which does mention sugar, and the following discussions:
Black coffee - Straight Dope Message Board
What is the definition of drinking your coffee black?
Invalid Link Removed

Probably the thing is, sugar simply didn't count in the original French and 18th century English calque but it very much does now, so "black" has become synonymous with "pure" in this case (funnily enough, since it's the opposite in many others) as you said.

This is one of those areas where usage rules over prescriptive norm, and if a substantial majority of native speakers say it means milkless and sugarless, then milkless+sugarless it is, or at least that becomes the primary definition: that's why I simply acknowledged the expanded meaning of the phrase shown in most posts here.
 
I like coffee in my coffee, nothing else. Some places I go to get all confused when I order coffee sand don't want cream and sugar.

I've had that before, particularly with espresso as well, usually my response to the espresso one is, "the only thing a shot of good espresso needs is a shot of good whiskey to chase it."

Coffee, water, heat, drink.
I've never had a cappuccino, frappuccino, ole', foam, froth or any of the other fancy coffees that are harder to spell than drink.

They're okay sometimes, I don't always want it black, but usually that's how I'll take it - black, and with the darkest roast you have.