Chef, I got the 5 speed, although after the fact I was reading that the auto tranny may actually get better mileage because it's geared higher than the manual. Mine tachs at around 3500 at 70 mph. It's probably negligible. We also have a 5 speed Honda Element, which has the Accord 2.4L 4-cyl engine, and it has the same rpm at 70mph. I've got 2500 miles on the Scion, and it's holding at about 35 mpg around town.
