TapyTap was asking about the difference between the tones. Assuming he meant the difference between Neck and Bridge p-up, despite their proximity to eachother, I find a huge difference between them.
That is my train of thought.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
TapyTap was asking about the difference between the tones. Assuming he meant the difference between Neck and Bridge p-up, despite their proximity to eachother, I find a huge difference between them.
Thanks manjushri.
I am assuming that your Thumb has the "wider" pickup spacing with the "neck" pickup closer to the P-bass position. I have seen some Thumbs with the two pickups very close to each other at the bridge...wavey davey's new Clement comes to mind in this regard.
It sounds like your Thumb has a simple grounding problem. I have heard that the Q-Tuners are extremely quiet. It will probably be a simple fix.
I am still curious as to your chosen pickup locations on the Clement. However you choose to center them, those three rows of pole pieces on each BL should be interesting to tweak (Although it seems that all pole pieces up could be just perfect).
Thanks for the comments - much appreciated!
Here is the finished bass... Perfect!!!
Hope you like it...
#181 arrived today in fine shape. I'm in love. First impressions: it's visually beautiful. the redwood top just glows, and the black hardware sets it off nicely. The build quality is really high - it was clearly made by a thoughtful craftsman. The neck is incredibly comfortable, even for a 5. It has almost no taper from 12th to 1st fret which took me a couple minutes to get used to - not a problem just different. It's comfortable around the neck and sitting (better than a J body), not heavy at all (will weigh it and report back).
#181 arrived today in fine shape. I'm in love. First impressions: it's visually beautiful. the redwood top just glows, and the black hardware sets it off nicely. The build quality is really high - it was clearly made by a thoughtful craftsman. The neck is incredibly comfortable, even for a 5. It has almost no taper from 12th to 1st fret which took me a couple minutes to get used to - not a problem just different. It's comfortable around the neck and sitting (better than a J body), not heavy at all (will weigh it and report back).
Tom, the action is unbelievably low. It really threw me at first; I'm used to digging in. This bass as set up requires a light touch. However, now that I'm getting used to it, it just may spoil me for my other basses! It is almost a revelation how fast and easy this thing is to play, and the action is flawless from fret 1 to fret 24.
For tone, it has mwaaaaah that just won't quit. With the bridge (J) pickup, it just crys and develops a note for a few seconds, like wmaaaaooouuww, like Jaco was playing a fretted P-Bass by comparison. I have a PJ setup; the split P pickup at the neck is not really very P-like. It also has a growly mwah that I'm really going to have to figure out how to use to good effect. I can't see this bass standing in for a P-bass at all - it's got too distinct and unique a tone of its own. The sustain is incredible, especially for a fretless - I actually had to check to make sure I didn't have my compressor pedal on. I think the mahogany body has something to do with this? Absolutely Sick. The output was a bit low for my tastes but I tweaked the pickup heights and preamp trimmer which brought it more in line with my own preferences.
Thanks, Tom, it is a great sounding and looking instrument. Pictures and maybe even some sound clips in the future.
![]()

Link Removed
Finally, the promised Phoenix sound sample.
Excellent! Thank you for taking the time to record and share this with us. What a fantastic sound you have there!
*hehe* that's ok, ask away, I'll try to answer as best as I can, and I'm sure Tom can chip in on the rest!!OK, now I am compelled to ask you some questions:
First off, how long is the scale length on your Phoenix bass? (Please forgive me if you have already answered any of my questions elsewhere, and I missed it somehow.)
Good question!Did you have Tom wire the Q-Tuner in series or parallel? (I am assuming it is wired in series.)
I'm sure Tom has this, or I could make a measurement. It's pretty close to the bridge. We've been experimenting with pickup positions, based on our Tundra basses (I've had three similar swamp ash fretless basses). I think we chose the pickup position close to the bridge as on my Tundra IV (#69) because that bass has a real singy fretless sound.How did you determine the current location of your Q-Tuner. In fact, do you know what the exact measurement (mm or inches) is from the center/middle row of pole pieces to the nut? (Erno Zwaan, the man behind the Q-Tuners, says that changing the pickup placement by just a few millimeters makes quite a difference in the balance between lows and mid/high frequencies.)
One more question: are three rows of pole pieces all up in this recording?
Thanks, thanks, and more thanks!
Bryan
The Q-tuner is somewhat old, I've had it for a couple years in a Cort Curbow bass (it really made that instrument stand out from the crowd!!). It had only one wire come out from it, and it's wired in as any other magnetic. So I'm assuming it's wired in parallell internally, since it's noice cancelling. If it was wired in series it wouldn't cancel the noise, or am I wrong now???? *lol* All I can say is that it's two leads are wired "normally" to the balance control as you would wire any magnetic pickup.