Gosh darn it Vic and your Ash favoritism!

I am torn between these for the future reverse PJ 5er:
Quilt Maple on Ash/Braz neck,
Quilt Maple on Alder/Braz neck
Alder/Braz neck
This bass will be specific to the blues stuff. I've been thinking of settling for a Fender P ($1200) or a Metro PJ ($2700) or order a custom NYC ($????).

Steer me in the right direction guys and gals....
BluesyCat,
I have been playing Blues Bass for the past 20 years with a sprinkling of funk/jazz/pop and rock/soul before that. When I read your post re what would be the best choice of instruments for backing up blues players i was, of course, very interested and thought i'd offer my .02.
I have used a myriad of different manufactureres and styles of basses trying to lock in on what I thought would be the "right" sound for supporting blues artists and have found that there is no "right" instrument. IMHO, the the most wonderful thing about playing blues music (provided you're not playing in a "like the record" cover situation) is the freedom to create and develop your own signature sound and apply it to generic blues structures. Other than the need to duplicate an acoustic sound (i.e. "Willie Dixon" style) my Sadowsky basses, vintage JJ5, 24fret 5-string(that I no longer have) and a relatively new standard P/J 5 have performed beyond expectations. With the way these basses can be EQ'd for me it comes down to who I'm backing up, the type of venue, and what bass will I be comfortable playing. If I do get into a jam, 95% of the time the Sadowsky basses allow me to EQ my way out of it.
The JJ5 is an ash/maple, solid body, SC, NYC that I bought new in 1999. It has been my "horse".
NONE of the blues artists that I back up have ever made a bad comment to me regarding sound, my chops, on the other hand yes

, but sound, no. On my most recent session (John Stephan Band "Know Your Driver") I laid down duplicate tracks on a few of the tunes using this bass and an old 1965 Fender refin'd P. The Engineer used the Sadowsky tracks for all but one of those selections.
I've used the 24-5 with guys who like their blues a little funky or in rooms that had too much acoustic "bounce". It was ash/maple w/ Soaps.
The P/J 5 is new to me as of last January but is really liked by one guy in particular who really digs the "thump". It is std routing, Alder/BRW and with the ability to blend or single P and J PU's I have yet to find a mix that this bass gets lost in. I personally think this thing could set off the seismographs down at the U of W.
I hope this is helpful. I realize that much of our work entails playing scripted "parts" in certain "ways" with recognizable "tones" but I say play what sounds good to you and let the music fold into YOUR strengths...who knows maybe you'll invent a new concept to an already established genre.
\
with respect
tr