A younger guy at the bar and I started a book club. I am rereading old books from high school that I remember liking. We are on Catcher in the Rye as he never read it in high school. Totally different take the second time around.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
This year I just finished the classic War and Peace, a very different take on Napoleons’ failure and self destruction on his retreat. 1300+ pages, it took me six months.
View attachment 5033446
I know that many russians read german writers like Kafka, Mann, Kant even during the dark times of world war II.
but our news publications continue to describe cultural events in Western and Eastern countries, people are interested in this. And there is not a bit of politics there.
Despite the novel's title, the war never seemed important. It has always been viewed only as a background for what is happening in the souls of the heroes. Thanks for your approach.
I studied at a Russian-language immersion school in the late 60s at a place that was headed by Tolstoy's youngest daughter Alexandra Lvovna. There were shelves full of editions of W&P in I forget how many languages. The students were trying to read original editions, which was interesting because they were written using the pre-revolutionary alphabet in some cases and used French when the aristocrats were talking to each other. Ms. Tolstoy was essentially a monarchist who had no time for anything post-revolution but did give some great insight into her father's writing process and pre-Soviet life. When I later later read it in English it gave a different and useful perspective.It's nice to see that the problems of recent years have not reduced interest in Russian writers.
Surprisingly different approach. Here (I’m from Russia), “War and Peace” is included in the school curriculum, and schoolchildren mostly joke about the fact that it is impossible to read so many pages. In literature lessons, we looked at the inner world and maturation of heroes, their spiritual growth and moral pain. We didn't consider the historical context of the book at all. If you ask a hundred random people in Russia what this book is about, everyone will say that it’s about Natasha Rostova, Andrei Bolkonsky and Pierre Bezukhov, but no one will remember about Napoleon. Despite the novel's title, the war never seemed important. It has always been viewed only as a background for what is happening in the souls of the heroes. Thanks for your approach.
Seems his generation was pretty reticent to talk about their experiences...
Not a book but a great mini series called “ The Pacific” Stephen Spielberg and Tom Hanks produced this very moving work. Many scenes are not easy to watch and some of what is portrayed is unspeakably sad but it is a laudable achievement. WWII was my dad’s war and it’s always interested me. I’ve read many many books on various aspects of the war in the pacific. Curiously, I knew very little about what my dad had done until I was about 36. Seems his generation was pretty reticent to talk about their experiences. Still fascinated by a genre that grew up in a real depression, “Grapes of Wrath”, stuff and then went on to willingly enlist and fight in a world war. Way to easy to make facile comparisons between life in America then and now, but the men and women of that generation have my undying admiration and respect.
WWII was my dad’s war and it’s always interested me. I’ve read many many books on various aspects of the war in the pacific. Curiously, I knew very little about what my dad had done until I was about 36. Seems his generation was pretty reticent to talk about their experiences. Still fascinated by a genre that grew up in a real depression, “Grapes of Wrath”, stuff and then went on to willingly enlist and fight in a world war. Way to easy to make facile comparisons between life in America then and now, but the men and women of that generation have my undying admiration and respect.