Hi Folks,
I'm new to this thread, but this subject is pretty big for me. For some folks like me, how it looks and sometimes which famous players the instrument was associated with can really color how you think about and play the instrument.
Naturally if there is something ergonomically wrong with the bass, such as a neck being too long, or a thumb rest in the wrong place is a deal killer for sure.
But I am definitely going to wind-up approaching a hollowbody Guild Starfire bass very differently than a J bass, a Stingray or a Rick, all of which I've played exclusively during my different musical "periods". Its both head, heart and hands. It's got to work on all levels. And their are more choices now than ever!
And, Maxdusty, I owned and played an original longhorn back in my early fusion shredder days, as back in 1969 it was the only full 2 octave bass available. It was great if you want to play bass like John McLaughlin. They have their uses. My problem is that I love so basses and guitars. Except the MM Bongo and Steinbergers LOL. I guess everyone has their no-go areas. I just could not make friends with Steinbergers.