Just wondering. I tend to play right behind the fret, almost like I was playing fretless. Does it matter that I am not playing in the middle of the space between frets?
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Does it matter were between the frets you play?
- Thread starter wazzel
- Start date
Isn't it more energy consuming to play right in the middle and therefor you should play just behind the fret for minimal tension to avoid injuries etc. ?
Ofcourse the pitch is the same always
Ofcourse the pitch is the same always
Yep to the question in the thread title. Your technique is considered the better one as it minimizes fret buzzing and requires less force.
I was once told by a guitarist that you should play in the middle between the frets. I later found that it was MUCH easier to play just behind them.
It's good practice too in case you want to switch to fretless.
I was told both. Behind the fret by bass players from here and in the middle by guitar players.
But, I've found on my bass anyway, it depends on where you play. On some frets I don't notice a change in pitch if I play right behind the fret. On some frets I've noticed that the pitch does indeed go sharp. Didn't really notice until my guitar player, who has a very good ear, kept hearing something out of pitch on a song. Checked me, I was on the right fret but it still sounded out, sure enough when I move to the middle of the fret it was right on.
Personally I don't find it any harder or easier to play behind the fret or right in the middle, and for my bass, it doesn't seem to make any difference in fret noise. FYI, I'm playing a 4 string bongo with a stock set up as far as action.
But, I've found on my bass anyway, it depends on where you play. On some frets I don't notice a change in pitch if I play right behind the fret. On some frets I've noticed that the pitch does indeed go sharp. Didn't really notice until my guitar player, who has a very good ear, kept hearing something out of pitch on a song. Checked me, I was on the right fret but it still sounded out, sure enough when I move to the middle of the fret it was right on.
Personally I don't find it any harder or easier to play behind the fret or right in the middle, and for my bass, it doesn't seem to make any difference in fret noise. FYI, I'm playing a 4 string bongo with a stock set up as far as action.
Yes. It "can".
If you play too far from the fret the note can go slightly flat.
Now, being that bass, guitar, etc. aren't perfectly intonated up the neck, sometimes playing further from the fret will actually make you more "in tune" than playing behind the fret.
If you play too far from the fret the note can go slightly flat.
Now, being that bass, guitar, etc. aren't perfectly intonated up the neck, sometimes playing further from the fret will actually make you more "in tune" than playing behind the fret.
Correct, but it goes sharp. This is more noticable on guitars.
Play directly behind the fret for both. It takes the least effort and it's usually the most in-tune (assuming your intonation is set properly)
I have always been told that good technique is to finger just behind or on top of the fret.
i n practice i pay less attention to ti than I ought too.
i n practice i pay less attention to ti than I ought too.
True, but I only experience that when I press in pretty hard, if I press the string without too much pressure it gives out the same tone over the length of the entire fret.
Just behind the fret for intonation reasons (although I agree its much more noticeable on guitar than bass). Also makes any long stretch you would have to make down the fretboard just a little bit shorter. Not a big deal I know, but if you have relatively small hands and play 35" plus scale basses its a useful habit to get into.
This would be caused typically by the downward increase of tension as the string is depressed to the fingerboard. Close to the fret this is less of a factor since the tension relative to the fret is much greater nearer to the fret and requires greater force to press the string to the fret board.
If someone has high frets or tends to press down very hard this will also be more of an occurrence.
I would say in the case of ric1312's post that if some notes are sharp at the fret there must be a tendency to bend the note for some reason that you are less likely to do I the middle of the fret. The reason I make that conclusion is because, as I pointed out above, the string would be pulled sharp, if anything once in the middle of the frets.
I would always recommend playing closer to the fret personally since I agree that it is much more efficient and also good "practice" for fretless playing.
I have big fingertips. So in the lower registers I can adjust it so I play just behind the fret. But in the higher areas, my fingertips tend to fill up most (or all) of teh gap between frets, so I'm not as finicky about it past the seventh fret as adjsuting it doesn't really 'work' for me in that area of the neck.
