• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Earliest Known P/J?

@Tanner5382I think he's a good guitar player.

I can take all the hunting and beloin-cloth'd anti-environmental wingnuttery as it is highly entertaining, but I wouldn't go so far as to say he's a good guitar player. One trick pony, showboating and formulaic. The same sort of base-emotion non-cerebral entertainment that Kiss pumped out, but dressed up as a backwoods hardnut rather than a gaggle of goofy space warriors. Music is never going to be the focus for those guys, merely a vector for their overall schtick. Ted hasn't progressed as a musician since the Amboy Dukes and, to be fair, hasn't really had to. He believes he's the best guitarist.

Stu Cook of CCR modified his P bass with a second P pickup, and later on added the toaster from his Rickenbacker to the neck position on the P. Not a PJ, but maybe an early adopter of the notion that a P bass could be bettered with a second pickup at the bridge.
 
Jack Casady in 1967, on a PJJ

6911513bb835385ee203f4a420ff15c0.jpg
 
I doubt if they were first, but Alembic was using a combination of P & J pickups on some of their 'Persuader' model basses in 1983.
 
Leo Fender used a strung up neck bolted to a piece of scrap wood with a bridge to mount and test pickups on. When he invented the dual coil p pickup he tested it next to a single coil.
//thread-CLOSED
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobyoung53
You were right about the bb2000 dr cheese

Yamaha 1979

View attachment 1105402
But given that the bass with a P and 2 Js has been eliminated - can the BB be counted as a PJ since itès actually a PR (Precision/Rail).
In my mind they are definitely part of that category - but they DON'T have a J pickup in them (well they do as of this year....).
So far (to my mind) the Ibanez is winning in the production sweeps.
 
I can take all the hunting and beloin-cloth'd anti-environmental wingnuttery as it is highly entertaining, but I wouldn't go so far as to say he's a good guitar player. One trick pony, showboating and formulaic. The same sort of base-emotion non-cerebral entertainment that Kiss pumped out, but dressed up as a backwoods hardnut rather than a gaggle of goofy space warriors. Music is never going to be the focus for those guys, merely a vector for their overall schtick. Ted hasn't progressed as a musician since the Amboy Dukes and, to be fair, hasn't really had to. He believes he's the best guitarist.

Stu Cook of CCR modified his P bass with a second P pickup, and later on added the toaster from his Rickenbacker to the neck position on the P. Not a PJ, but maybe an early adopter of the notion that a P bass could be bettered with a second pickup at the bridge.

Gotta disagree on that, personally. I think some of his instrumental tracks have some downright great guitar playing, like Hibernation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Barbaric.Eric