The old adage that youre just gonna have to try them out yourself definitely applies, but...... Ive had a ton of Stingrays, and a handful of Classics. Ive heard the whole argument of 2band vs. 3band many times and honestly the difference is slight compared to the difference between other basses. They all sound "like a Stingray". If Stingrays were coffee one has a dash more sweetener and one has a dash more cream but you would enjoy both. The Special can do every tone I love from either and its just slightly more pleasing. Its brewed from a better bean. It still sounds "like a Stingray" though. Its just that maybe that sweetener is real cane sugar instead of splenda and they used real cream instead of 2%. Ive got the HH and Im impressed with its versatility and I only moderately adjust my onboard EQ. With greater adjustments it still sounds "right". I think it can be used for pretty much everything out there. It does a great "vintage" tone if you ask me, but I guess that truly depends on what your idea of "vintage" is.