I'll agree that the roasted maple can sometimes be dark enough to not look like maple. If I compare my Special to my Big Al, which has a un-roasted maple fretboard (that model was unfortunately discontinued before SBMM started roasting their maple boards), the difference is a big one. They don't look like the same woods.
Considering my particular Special, I don't mind it at all. The coloring fits the color scheme of the bass really well. On other colors/finishes, I can see opinions being different.
I wasn't actually the one who bought the tort guard. The previous owner replaced the original white with this tort and a parchment and included all three in the sale (on top of a great price!). They all work nicely and give it three distinct looks that I can easily change. But, I'm a hardcore tort guy, so you can probably guess how often I change them. LOL
Considering my particular Special, I don't mind it at all. The coloring fits the color scheme of the bass really well. On other colors/finishes, I can see opinions being different.
I wasn't actually the one who bought the tort guard. The previous owner replaced the original white with this tort and a parchment and included all three in the sale (on top of a great price!). They all work nicely and give it three distinct looks that I can easily change. But, I'm a hardcore tort guy, so you can probably guess how often I change them. LOL

