• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

EllenPlaysBass plays a,,,

I may be the only person that can't watch that girl's videos. "she's so cute and look at the fun she has" the joyous spirit painted on and that fake smile I just can't. It's about sucking in the views for $$ and any female playing bass gets tons more attention in a vastly male playing field. She does have a lot of help from mom and dad and lucky for her.
She is getting better at playing but I don't see her as any prodigy. I won't be buying a Sterling.
But hey if I don't dig her stuff that's just more for you!

:thumbsdown:
 
I may be the only person that can't watch that girl's videos. "she's so cute and look at the fun she has" the joyous spirit painted on and that fake smile I just can't. It's about sucking in the views for $$ and any female playing bass gets tons more attention in a vastly male playing field. She does have a lot of help from mom and dad and lucky for her.
She is getting better at playing but I don't see her as any prodigy. I won't be buying a Sterling.
But hey if I don't dig her stuff that's just more for you!

Could be worse. She could be the Lil Tay of the bass world.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Seth DuSith
Very true on being a “personality” too early on. But does seem like her parents are really keeping a handle on her career and monitoring her celebrity. Personally, not sure it’d be something I might allow, IMO. Hoping though they stoke other fires just in case she hits a road block or just loses interest entirely. You know how growing up can be. She seems (for now) pretty well adjusted and still enjoying it all. Good for her. :thumbsup:

Regarding the Sterlings and Markbass equipment. Good stuff, but I’m set with what I like. I’m sure the marketing ain’t aimed for a craggy jaded doofus like me.:laugh:

What happens when she wants to quit? It’s going to happen at some point.

If she was a child actor in CA, she’s at least have a Coogan account and other protections in place. Don’t think that’s necessarily the case here.
 
Does every opinion need to be validated by an online personality nowadays?

I'll validate any opinion for $39.95!

hqdefault.jpg
 
lots of opinions and projections without any evidence of what is true.

nobody lives in that house on this forum. you have no idea whether she likes it or hates it. no clue if she is being abused or if she is the one pushing to do this because she loves it. no idea of her parents or if they are getting deals for what instrument she plays or which one she actually prefers.

why so nasty without any idea of what is true?
 
why so nasty without any idea of what is true?

Honestly?
Probably this:

'Cause, as a bunch of aging bassists who've been in the trenches for literally decades pouring our heart and soul out for whatever pay they're shilling out, we're flat out jealous of a kid that hasn't even reached the age of consent running circles around our lifelong pursuit of musical validation.

(Not excusing the cold shoulder, just offering a highly likely reason for it)
 
Ellen certainly appears to enjoy playing very much, and has made videos regarding her path of development as a player, her initial choice of instrument (ie the bass), and so on. She's making choices, with guidance, and putting in the work, and has been rewarded with meeting and playing with some of her heroes, like Victor Wooten, Steve Vsai, Bootsey, EW&F, and others. If there's a dark side there, as some have asserted without evidence, I can't see it. Happy and accomplished kid, by the available evidence. People's minds go to odd places sometimes.

And yes, she plays long scale too, even a 5 string fretless for some Jaco Pastorius! How many TBers got that covered? Not me :).

 
Last edited:
I'm glad to see I'm not the only person who finds Ellen's YouTube channel to be problematic. And, no, it's not jealousy: I would have given up the bass decades ago if I was troubled by young people who are better than me. At first, her joy in playing and all the giggles seemed authentic, contagious and cute. After a while, it all seemed a bit weird and distasteful. Just my opinion.
 
lots of opinions and projections without any evidence of what is true.

nobody lives in that house on this forum. you have no idea whether she likes it or hates it. no clue if she is being abused or if she is the one pushing to do this because she loves it. no idea of her parents or if they are getting deals for what instrument she plays or which one she actually prefers.

why so nasty without any idea of what is true?

Kids also don’t necessarily realize the implications of what their parents involve them in.

Look at Brooke Shields. Her mom should have been put in jail.

Heck, google “Dan Schneider” - Nickelodeon producer who was responsible for a lot of hits, and you’ll be grossed out that he had a career for so long.

Point is, it’s exploitative to throw your kids into entertainment as a career when they don’t have the legal capacity to do basically anything on their own.

Even if she is pushing to do it, it’s the job of a parent to say “Eat your veggies and focus on your schoolwork.”
 
Kids also don’t necessarily realize the implications of what their parents involve them in.

Look at Brooke Shields. Her mom should have been put in jail.

Heck, google “Dan Schneider” - Nickelodeon producer who was responsible for a lot of hits, and you’ll be grossed out that he had a career for so long.

Point is, it’s exploitative to throw your kids into entertainment as a career when they don’t have the legal capacity to do basically anything on their own.

Even if she is pushing to do it, it’s the job of a parent to say “Eat your veggies and focus on your schoolwork.”
-- --
So now this kid is Brooke Shields? Alrighty then. Like. I said, people get some odd ideas.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gorilla Monsoon