• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

"Esperanza Spalding Is The 21st Century's Jazz Genius"

bholder

Affable Sociopath
Gold Supporting Member
Supporting Member
Sep 2, 2001
32,358
87,044
Vestal, NY
Disclosures
Received a gift from Sire* (see sig)
ttt-esperanza-spalding-edit_custom-7add6df824cae3e27a4da59d44b133abec6fc896-s800-c85.jpg

Esperanza Spalding Is The 21st Century's Jazz Genius

Discuss.
 
Yeah, a little premature, I’d add “so far” to that. It begs the question, will there be jazz in 2099? Will playing actual instruments, with other people in real time, in the same room(and using a wide range of notes), be a dismissible, quaint notion? Oh, and there will be a ‘crime of the century’ or three to get through in the next 80 some years as well.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mikewalker
Super talented? Yes.
Super creative? Sure.
Does her music "hit me" in that place where I want to hear it more than once? No.

+1. Would love to see her live though. Here’s an interesting [Invalid or Expired Link Removed], in which he describes her playing as pointless. He also dogs on Stanley Clarke, and calls Herbie Hancock crap. He comes off a bit of a jerk, but I thought it was kind of funny.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mikewalker
+1. Would love to see her live though. Here’s an interesting [Invalid or Expired Link Removed], in which he describes her playing as pointless. He also dogs on Stanley Clarke, and calls Herbie Hancock crap. He comes off a bit of a jerk, but I thought it was kind of funny.
Anyone who thinks Stanley Clark & Herbie Hancock are crap is not someone whose opinion I take seriously. I went through a listening to Bill Laswell phase - for about 6 months - but I have been enjoying and listening to Herbie Hancock & Stanley Clark for 40 years and it still doesn't get old. I have never understood why musicians feel the need to talk crap about eachother - like Joe Zawinul constantly putting Jaco down. Just seems like deep seated insecurity to me. Esperanza Spalding has earned her accolades, whether I like her music or not. More power to her - it ain't easy being a female musician - especially in jazz.
 
she's a good bass player. many people can play the crap out of electric, upright, classical, jazz, and compose. (patitucci is the first that jumps into my head) i havent heard her do authentic latin stuff yet, and there are guys out there that can do all of the above plus the latin thing, so there's that...then you have guys like eddie gomez and marc johnson who are more narrow in scope but go very, very deep in that scope...