Evanescence video OMG

[Gia]

evanescence are just a rip off of lacuna coil.

but a really really bad one.

 

[Atshen]

evanescence are just a rip off of lacuna coil.

Sad thing is, most people think it's the other way around... :scowl:

 

[tufnuts]

Wow is correct amy.

The drums sounded like there were outta tune also. Everything was just outta tune. Wow.

That's all. Anything else would just be nasty

 

[Gia]

Sad thing is, most people think it's the other way around... :scowl:

yeah, that makes me extremely angry!

i always try to educate evaneceawljkea fans about lacuna coil.

 

[keb]

Train wreck ahoy!

 

[Benjamin Strange]

I started watching this, and I was thinking "God, this is bad". Then the guitars came in and I thought "Oh. This is supposed to be the bad part".

 

[B-NoteCowboy]

dumb question, but what show is this from? I'm trying to find some sort of mention of it in google, and I'm coming up dry.

 

[Lyle Caldwell]

Ben,
Yeah, I hope the video "quality" is responsible for her sound, cause otherwise her pitch is bad and her voice is mumbly.

 

[Only]

I'd just like to say that I've seen Lacuna Coil live, and they were every bit as bad as this video, if not worse.

 

[Gia]

i have no idea how to open that file

 

[Suckbird]

I'm not a big fan of her voice either,
but i remember i heard somebody say she's not playing synth/piano and in this video she just did the moves,
how ugly isn't that?

 

[Gia]

That Amy's no Christina is she?

hell no!

Link Removed

 

[keb]

I wonder what the players in that string section thought afterwards. "God, what a bunch of noobs. Oh well. Paycheck."

 

[Benjamin Strange]

I'm not a big fan of her voice either,
but i remember i heard somebody say she's not playing synth/piano and in this video she just did the moves,
how ugly isn't that?

Yeah, I saw that too. Her fingers weren't moving in synch with the sound at all.

 

[Gia]

oh my god.
i just figured out how to open it.

it's worse (and more hilarious) than i ever could have imagined.

 

[Benjamin Strange]

That's just not true. She's either playing it or faking it in a manner that shows she can play it. No idea if they "play" this song "live" normally - but obviously the band is playing live so why not her?

On the clip I have, her fingers aren't anywhere close to what is actually being heard. I don't doubt that she can play piano. Perhaps an audio delay or something is the issue?

 

[odie]

Actually she can and does play. Seen their DVD and other live videos. She does play a good number of the piano parts. Who is to say the show wouldnt let her play keys.

As for the Lacuna Coil comment. I saw them live once and I was blown away by how good she sounded. Maybe you caught a bad show.??

 

[refinedbass]

Amy didn't do a very good job at covering up the screw-ups either. It's almost like she made sure to let everyone know, "Hey, it wasn't me who screwed up, it was these morons behind me." I always thought that, at that high a level, even if you do screw up, don't show it, cause half the people out in the crowd and watching don't know the difference anyways, until you let them know.

Forgive my ignorance on this one, if I'm wrong, but why did they have a keyboard in a grand piano casing or does Baldwin make that??

 

[Gia]

As for the Lacuna Coil comment. I saw them live once and I was blown away by how good she sounded. Maybe you caught a bad show.??

yeah! i've seen lacuna coil twice and christina's voice was perfect, and the band was really tight too.

 

[Atshen]

Forgive my ignorance on this one, if I'm wrong, but why did they have a keyboard in a grand piano casing or does Baldwin make that??

That would be an impressively stupid idea, kinda like carrying your bass guitar in an upright flight case.